The Washington Court of Appeals recently ruled in the case of Joseph Daniel Kingdon v. Elizabeth Josephine Kingdon, affirming the denial of Elizabeth's request to modify child support payments. The decision affects the couple's two children and highlights the complexities of post-divorce financial arrangements.
In 2021, Joseph and Elizabeth Kingdon divorced, and as part of their settlement, Joseph was ordered to pay $2,800 in monthly spousal maintenance and $98 in monthly child support. After the expiration of the spousal maintenance in August 2025, Elizabeth believed that the child support amount was insufficient and filed a petition to modify the child support order. Her request was denied by a superior court commissioner, leading her to appeal the decision.
The dispute centers on Elizabeth's claim that she was experiencing severe economic hardship due to the termination of spousal maintenance. She argued that this change warranted a modification of the child support payments. Elizabeth presented evidence of her financial situation, including her income from a small skincare business and her available cash assets, which she claimed were being depleted to cover essential expenses.
Joseph opposed Elizabeth's petition, arguing that her financial situation did not constitute a severe economic hardship. He pointed out that Elizabeth had over $100,000 in assets, owned a home valued at $1 million, and traveled frequently, which he claimed indicated she was not in dire financial straits.
The superior court commissioner ultimately denied Elizabeth's petition, stating that the end of spousal maintenance was not an unforeseen change and that both parties had sufficient income to support their children. Elizabeth then filed a motion for reconsideration, introducing new claims about her decreasing business income, but this motion was also denied.
Elizabeth subsequently appealed the denial of her motion for revision to the superior court, where she argued that the court had failed to properly calculate her income and consider all evidence related to her business. However, the superior court upheld the commissioner's decision, stating that the loss of spousal maintenance was anticipated and did not constitute a substantial change in circumstances.
The court ruled, "Given the fact that there will be a remedy for the wife, [Elizabeth], come September, without having to demonstrate extreme hardship... I’m going to deny that motion to revise." The superior court also noted that Elizabeth would have another opportunity to adjust child support in September 2026, when the order would be eligible for modification without needing to demonstrate a substantial change in circumstances.
In addition to denying the motion to revise, the superior court awarded Joseph $1,500 in attorney fees, citing a local court rule. However, the Court of Appeals later reversed this award, stating that the basis for the attorney fees was improper. The court clarified that the local rule did not provide a legal basis for awarding attorney fees.
The court's decision underscores the importance of demonstrating a substantial change in circumstances when seeking modifications to child support orders. It also highlights the challenges faced by individuals navigating post-divorce financial arrangements, particularly when business income is involved.
Looking forward, this ruling indicates that individuals seeking to modify child support must provide clear and compelling evidence of changes in their financial circumstances. The decision may also serve as a reference point for future cases involving child support modifications in Washington state.
As for next steps, Elizabeth may have the option to appeal the decision further, but details were not available in the court filing regarding any pending related cases.
Read Next
Washington Court of Appeals rules on LNG facility costs
Court rules on Puget Sound Energy rate hike dispute
Court reverses eviction ruling in Seattle housing case
Vermont court denies motion to amend wrongful death complaint
Vermont court dismisses eviction case against Catherine Morrill
Vermont court rules on timber harvest dispute case









