The Tennessee Court of Appeals has reversed a lower court's decision that dismissed claims from Fair Lane Properties, LLC against the Metropolitan Government of Nashville and Davidson County. The court ruled that the trial court erred in determining that Fair Lane's claims were barred by the statute of limitations. This ruling is significant for property owners who may face similar disputes regarding permitting conditions imposed by local governments.

Fair Lane Properties, LLC, owned multiple properties on Alloway Street in Davidson County. In November 2024, the company filed a complaint against Metro, alleging that the city unlawfully imposed paving conditions as part of its building permit process. Fair Lane claimed that it was forced to pay over $69,000 to pave the streets and alleys surrounding its properties, which it argued constituted an unconstitutional taking of property without just compensation.

The dispute began when Fair Lane sought building permits for its properties. As a condition for these permits, Metro required the company to cover the costs of paving the entire street and alleys adjacent to its properties. Fair Lane's initial complaint included claims for declaratory relief and a common law writ of certiorari, seeking the return of construction costs. In March 2025, Fair Lane amended its complaint to include additional claims related to violations of the takings clause of both the U.S. and Tennessee constitutions, as well as claims for inverse condemnation and unjust enrichment.

Metro responded by filing a motion to dismiss Fair Lane's claims, arguing that they were time-barred. The trial court agreed and dismissed the case, stating that Fair Lane's claims were not filed within the applicable statutes of limitations. However, Fair Lane appealed this decision, raising several issues regarding the trial court's ruling.

In its ruling, the Court of Appeals, led by Judge Andy D. Bennett, determined that the trial court had erred in dismissing Fair Lane's claims. The court noted that the statute of limitations for the state law taking claims and the federal law taking claims had not been properly applied. The court stated, "The allegations in the complaint do not establish that the statute of limitations barred Fair Lane’s state law taking claims." This finding was pivotal in reversing the lower court's decision.

The Court of Appeals found that the trial court incorrectly determined the date on which Fair Lane's claims accrued. Metro argued that the claims should have been considered time-barred from October 4, 2022, when the paving requirements were finalized. However, the appellate court ruled that Fair Lane was not made aware of the full extent of the paving requirements until later, thereby extending the timeline for filing its claims.

Additionally, the court addressed Fair Lane's claim for a common law writ of certiorari, which the trial court dismissed as untimely. The appellate court disagreed, stating that there was no final decision by a planning commission or tribunal that would trigger the sixty-day filing requirement for the writ. The court emphasized that Fair Lane's complaint did not establish that it was notified of Metro’s decision regarding the paving conditions on the date claimed by Metro.

Judge Bennett, along with Chief Judge Frank G. Clement, Jr., and Judge Jeffrey Usman, joined in the opinion, which reversed the trial court's dismissal and remanded the case for further proceedings. The appellate court's decision allows Fair Lane to pursue its claims against Metro, potentially setting a precedent for similar cases involving property owners and local government regulations.

This ruling is significant as it clarifies the application of statutes of limitations in cases involving property rights and governmental regulations. It reinforces the notion that property owners must be adequately informed of governmental actions affecting their property rights before the statute of limitations can begin to run.

Moving forward, the case will return to the trial court for further proceedings. Fair Lane Properties now has the opportunity to argue its claims against the Metropolitan Government of Nashville and Davidson County. The outcome of this case could have implications for other property owners facing similar disputes with local governments regarding permitting and regulatory conditions.

As of now, it is unclear if Metro plans to appeal the Court of Appeals' ruling. There are no related cases pending that have been mentioned in the court filing. The court has assessed the costs of the appeal against Metro, indicating that Fair Lane has prevailed in this stage of the legal battle.