The Tennessee Court of Appeals recently ruled against a motion for recusal filed by Michael Pigford, the son of Mary Gonia Pigford, in a conservatorship case. The court affirmed the lower court's decision, stating that the trial judge did not exhibit bias or partiality. This ruling is significant as it addresses issues of judicial impartiality and the standards required for recusal in legal proceedings.
The case, titled In Re Conservatorship of Mary Gonia Pigford, was filed under docket number W2026-01300-COA-T10B-CV. The ruling came from Judge Steven W. Maroney, who was joined by Judges Jeffrey Usman and William E. Phillips II. The decision affects the ongoing conservatorship of Mary Gonia Pigford, who has been under the care of a conservator since November 2023.
The background of this case involves a dispute over property ownership and the management of Ms. Pigford's estate. In 2019, Ms. Pigford executed quit-claim deeds transferring her property interests to family members, retaining possession of the deeds to be recorded only after her death. Michael Pigford, the appellant, recorded one of these deeds in July 2025, two years after the conservatorship was established. In May 2026, the trial court ordered the sale of Ms. Pigford's properties to fund her care, prompting the conservator to file a motion to set aside the Windward Deed that Michael Pigford had recorded.
Michael Pigford filed a motion for the recusal of Judge Kathleen N. Gomes, who presided over the conservatorship case. He alleged bias based on several grounds, including the judge's previous dismissal of his initial recusal motion and the fact that the conservator's attorney had previously served as a substitute judge. The trial court dismissed the initial motion due to procedural issues but later addressed the amended motion on its merits, ultimately denying it.
In its ruling, the court stated, "The party seeking recusal bears the burden of proof." The court found that Michael Pigford did not provide sufficient evidence to support his claims of bias against Judge Gomes. The court noted that adverse rulings alone do not constitute grounds for recusal, and the appellant failed to demonstrate how the judge's relationship with the conservator's attorney affected her impartiality.
The court examined the specific allegations made by Michael Pigford, including claims that the judge's conduct during hearings was biased against him and that he was not allowed to present his evidence adequately. The court concluded that the trial judge had acted appropriately and that the allegations did not indicate a reasonable basis for questioning her impartiality.
This ruling has implications for future cases involving motions for recusal in Tennessee. It reinforces the principle that mere disagreement with a judge's rulings does not warrant a recusal and emphasizes the need for concrete evidence of bias. The court's decision also highlights the importance of procedural compliance in filing motions for recusal, particularly for pro se litigants who represent themselves in court.
Moving forward, the case will continue in the lower court, where the conservatorship proceedings will be further addressed. Michael Pigford has the option to appeal the ruling, but it remains to be seen whether he will pursue that course of action.
In summary, the Tennessee Court of Appeals upheld the trial court's denial of the recusal motion, affirming that the judge acted impartially in the conservatorship case involving Mary Gonia Pigford. This decision clarifies the standards for recusal and the burden of proof required to establish claims of judicial bias.
Read Next
Tennessee Supreme Court Rules on Nashville Council Size Cap
Tennessee court upholds dismissal of Shawn Bough's appeal
Tennessee Court Upholds Convictions in Murder, Rape Case
Ninth Circuit affirms bankruptcy appeal dismissal in Cordero case
Court dismisses appeal in veterans benefits case Lavens v. Collins
Court affirms denial of records request in Ng v. Dept. of State










