NASHVILLE, Tenn. — The Tennessee Court of Appeals has vacated a juvenile court's ruling that denied a motion for the recusal of a trial judge in a case involving custody and visitation disputes. The decision, issued on November 17, 2026, affects Hector Antonio Figueroa, Jr., who sought the recusal after alleging bias in the handling of his case. The ruling emphasizes the importance of judicial impartiality and the need for courts to provide clear reasoning when denying recusal motions.
The case, identified as In Re Maddex B., et al., arose from a dependency and neglect proceeding initiated by the Tennessee Department of Children’s Services (DCS) against a mother and three fathers regarding four children. Mr. Figueroa was one of the fathers involved in the case. The dispute has been ongoing since September 2023, with multiple hearings held over the years, including several review hearings in 2024 and a permanent parenting plan entered in December 2025.
Mr. Figueroa, representing himself, filed a motion for the recusal of the trial judge on May 4, 2026. He claimed that the judge's actions created a cumulative appearance of partiality, citing unresolved motions and a perceived lack of timely responses from the court. The juvenile court denied his motion on June 10, 2026, stating that it was untimely and lacked legal basis. Figueroa appealed the decision, leading to a previous ruling by the Court of Appeals that vacated the denial and remanded the case for further consideration.
On October 2, 2026, the juvenile court issued a second order again denying the recusal motion. The court stated that there was no basis for Mr. Figueroa’s accusations of bias and that any reasonable person would not doubt the court's impartiality. The court also referenced previous orders that addressed some of the motions Figueroa claimed were unresolved. However, the Court of Appeals found that the juvenile court's reasoning was insufficient.
The Court of Appeals, led by Judge Carma Dennis McGee, ruled that the juvenile court failed to provide adequate written grounds for denying the recusal motion. The court stated, "The second recusal order does not sufficiently explain the trial court’s decision in a manner that would permit us to apply this objective test to decide if a person of ordinary prudence in the judge’s position, knowing all of the facts known to the judge, would find a reasonable basis for questioning the judge’s impartiality." This lack of clarity necessitated the court's decision to vacate the juvenile court's ruling and remand the case for further proceedings.
The ruling reinforces the necessity for judges to provide clear and comprehensive explanations when denying recusal motions. The Court of Appeals emphasized that judicial recusal is governed by Tennessee Supreme Court Rule 10B, which mandates that judges must state the grounds for denying such motions in writing. This requirement aims to ensure transparency and uphold the integrity of the judicial process.
Moving forward, the outcome of this case will have implications for Mr. Figueroa and the other parties involved in the custody and visitation disputes. The court's decision signals that the judicial system must maintain a high standard of impartiality and fairness, particularly in sensitive cases involving children.
The case may still be subject to further appeals, depending on the juvenile court's subsequent actions regarding the recusal motion. As of now, the court has been instructed to either grant the recusal or provide a detailed written explanation for its denial.
Read Next
Tennessee Supreme Court Rules on Nashville Council Size Cap
Tennessee court upholds dismissal of Shawn Bough's appeal
Tennessee Court Upholds Convictions in Murder, Rape Case
California Court rules on drug testing in juvenile case
California court rules on child support appeal case D087811
Court orders new trial in inmate's small claims case










