The California Court of Appeal has granted inmate Rodolfo A. Brambila a new trial in his small claims case against the Fresno County Sheriff’s Office. The court ruled that the small claims court had dismissed Brambila's case without allowing him to present his evidence through declarations, as permitted by law for incarcerated individuals. This decision affects Brambila and potentially sets a precedent for how small claims cases involving inmates are handled in the future.
Brambila filed his small claims action on March 18, 2025, claiming that the Fresno County jail lost or stole his courtroom attire, which he had entrusted to the facility. The items included a navy blazer, slacks, shirts, a tie, a belt, and shoes. The Sheriff’s Office, led by Sheriff John Zanoni, did not reimburse him for the loss. The small claims court dismissed his case on August 12, 2025, citing Brambila's failure to appear in person, despite the fact that California law allows inmates to submit declarations instead.
Brambila attempted to contest the dismissal by filing a motion on September 2, 2025, arguing that he was not required to appear personally. However, on the day of the hearing, prison officials did not allow him to participate via CourtCall, leading to another dismissal on October 15, 2025. Frustrated, Brambila sought a writ of mandate from the Court of Appeal, which initially denied his petition. Following a review by the California Supreme Court, the matter was sent back to the Court of Appeal for reconsideration.
In its ruling, the Court of Appeal stated, "Sheriff does not oppose the relief described in the sole 'issue presented' for relief and sought by [Brambila]... the right to appear in Fresno County Superior Court, Small Claims Division... by declarations or other permissible means as the Court may determine." The court found that Brambila was indeed entitled to submit declarations in lieu of personal appearance, as outlined in California's Code of Civil Procedure.
The court ordered the small claims court to vacate both the August 12 judgment and the October 15 order, and to conduct a new trial. The ruling emphasizes the importance of ensuring that inmates have the opportunity to present their cases fairly, even when they are unable to appear in person.
This decision could have broader implications for other inmates seeking to file small claims actions. It reinforces the legal rights of incarcerated individuals to participate in legal proceedings without being physically present, and it may encourage more inmates to pursue claims against government entities for lost or damaged property.
Looking ahead, it remains to be seen how the Fresno County Sheriff’s Office will respond to this ruling. The Sheriff’s Office has indicated a willingness to settle the matter, having offered Brambila $315 for the lost clothing. However, Brambila has expressed that this amount does not cover his total losses, including court costs and other expenses incurred due to the Sheriff's failure to reimburse him. As the case moves forward, both parties may need to negotiate a settlement that reflects the full extent of Brambila's claims.
Brambila's case highlights the challenges faced by inmates in navigating the legal system and the importance of ensuring their rights are upheld. The ruling serves as a reminder that the courts must provide fair access to justice for all individuals, regardless of their incarceration status.
Details were not available in the court filing regarding whether the case could be appealed further or if there are related cases pending. However, the court's decision to grant a new trial indicates a significant step in Brambila’s pursuit of justice regarding his lost property.
Read Next
California court upholds murder conviction of Thomas Woodson
Court denies attorney lien claim in Tusken v. Rubin case
California Court reverses summary judgment in abuse case
Court upholds dismissal of breach of contract claim in Vega case
Court affirms dismissal of RH Kids' title claim against lender
Court rules on attorney's alleged breach of duty in case










