A New Jersey appellate court has dismissed an appeal concerning the state's third solicitation for Offshore Wind Renewable Energy Certificates (OREC). This decision impacts local environmental groups and energy companies involved in offshore wind projects. The dismissal occurred on November 20, 2026, and it comes after the parties reached a mutual agreement.
The case, titled In the Matter of the Opening of New Jersey's Third Solicitation for Offshore Wind Renewable Energy Certificates, was filed under docket number A-1973-23. It involved multiple parties, including environmental organizations Protect Our Coast NJ and Defend Brigantine Beach, Inc., as well as energy companies such as Invenergy Wind Offshore LLC and Attentive Energy LLC.
This appeal arose from a decision made by the New Jersey Board of Public Utilities regarding the solicitation process for offshore wind energy projects. The dispute centered on the regulatory framework and the implications of the solicitation for local communities and environmental interests. The appellate court's ruling is significant as it reflects the ongoing tensions between renewable energy development and environmental protection in New Jersey.
Background
The parties involved in this case included appellants Protect Our Coast NJ, Defend Brigantine Beach, Inc., Suzanne Moore, and Mike Dean. These groups raised concerns about the environmental impacts of offshore wind projects and sought to challenge the Board of Public Utilities' decision to open a new solicitation for ORECs.
On the other side, the respondents included the New Jersey Division of Rate Counsel, represented by Brian O. Lipman and his team, as well as the New Jersey Board of Public Utilities, represented by Attorney General Jennifer Davenport. Additionally, Invenergy Wind Offshore LLC and Attentive Energy LLC were also involved, with legal representation from Saul Ewing LLP and Archer & Greiner PC, respectively.
The appeal was submitted to the court on November 10, 2026, and the parties had the opportunity to present their arguments regarding the implications of the solicitation for offshore wind energy development. However, the court did not specify the details of the arguments made by either side.
The Ruling
The court ruled to dismiss the appeal after the parties reached an amicable adjustment. The dismissal was noted as being without prejudice and deemed moot. This means that the case can be reopened in the future if necessary, but for now, it is considered resolved.
In the court's opinion, it stated, "this matter having been amicably adjusted and the parties having stipulated to the dismissal of this appeal, the appeal is dismissed without prejudice and as moot." The decision was made by Judges Gooden Brown and Firko, although the opinion did not provide further details about their reasoning.
Impact
The dismissal of this appeal has significant implications for the future of offshore wind energy projects in New Jersey. By resolving this dispute, the court allows the New Jersey Board of Public Utilities to proceed with its solicitation process for ORECs, which are essential for financing and supporting renewable energy projects.
This ruling may encourage further offshore wind development in the state, as it removes a legal hurdle that could have delayed projects. However, it also highlights the ongoing concerns from local environmental groups about the potential impacts of such developments on coastal ecosystems and communities.
What's Next
Details were not available in the court filing regarding whether this ruling can be appealed further. However, since the case has been dismissed as moot, it is unlikely that there will be any further legal action unless new issues arise related to the solicitation process.














