The Kentucky Court of Appeals has reversed a summary judgment that held Marty and Matt Nilest personally liable for debts related to their limited liability company (LLC). The ruling, issued on November 20, 2026, affects the Nilests and their business dealings, highlighting the importance of adhering to statutory requirements for LLCs. This decision underscores the legal protections available to LLC members under Kentucky law.
The case, known as Marty Nilest v. Roman Kusyo, was filed under docket number 2025-CA-0348. The dispute arose from a previous judgment against the Nilests’ LLC, which was found liable for damages in a separate case. After that ruling, the Kusyos amended their complaint to include the Nilests personally, seeking to pierce the LLC's veil and hold them accountable for the company's obligations.
The Jefferson Circuit Court initially granted the Kusyos' motion for summary judgment, concluding that the Nilests had failed to follow corporate formalities. However, the Nilests appealed this decision, arguing that the trial court did not properly consider Kentucky Revised Statute (KRS) 275.185(4), which provides specific protections for LLC members.
The Court of Appeals provided a detailed background on the case, referencing a previous ruling in All That N More, LLC v. Kusyo, where the court affirmed a default judgment against the LLC but remanded for a re-calculation of damages. The Nilests' appeal focused on the trial court's analysis of the factors necessary to pierce the veil of an LLC. The court noted that a successful veil-piercing claim requires proving both domination of the LLC and circumstances that would allow continued recognition of the LLC as a separate entity to promote injustice.
Judge Acree, writing for the court, stated, "The trial court failed to consider KRS 275.185(4) when determining whether, as a matter of law, the veil of the limited liability company’s existence could be pierced. That was error." The court emphasized that while the Nilests did not follow certain corporate formalities, KRS 275.185(4) protects LLC members from personal liability for failing to maintain records.
The court's ruling is significant as it clarifies the legal protections available to LLC members in Kentucky. The court highlighted that the statute in question has remained unchanged since its adoption in 1994, despite other changes to the law regarding LLCs. This ruling reinforces the idea that failure to maintain records alone does not justify piercing the veil of an LLC.
The impact of this ruling extends beyond the parties involved. It serves as a reminder to business owners about the importance of understanding and adhering to the legal requirements for operating an LLC. The decision may influence how courts approach similar cases in the future, particularly regarding the standards for piercing the veil of an LLC.
Moving forward, the case will return to the Jefferson Circuit Court for further proceedings. The trial court must now re-evaluate the Kusyos' motion for summary judgment in light of the appellate court's findings. The court has the discretion to determine how to proceed, whether by re-analyzing the motion or exploring other options.
This ruling may also have implications for related cases, especially as the Kentucky Supreme Court has pending discretionary review on similar issues involving LLC veil piercing. The outcome of such cases could further shape the legal landscape for LLCs in Kentucky.
Read Next
Kentucky Court Overturns Judgment Against Edward Penziner
Kentucky Court Orders Further Proceedings in Road Dispute
Court rules on whistleblower case involving housing authority
Alabama court terminates parental rights in custody case
Ohio court affirms denial of domestic violence protection order
Ohio Court reverses ruling in VineBrook Homes legal case










