The Ohio Court of Appeals has affirmed a summary judgment in favor of the City of Dayton regarding a personal injury case involving a police cruiser. The court ruled that the city is immune from liability because the police officer was responding to an emergency call when the incident occurred. This decision impacts the rights of individuals injured in similar circumstances and clarifies the legal standards surrounding police immunity.

The case, Neal v. Muradov, was filed under docket number 30610. The plaintiff, Michael Neal, was injured when he was struck by a Dayton Police Department cruiser driven by Officer Iskandar Muradov. The incident occurred on March 3, 2023, while Neal was crossing a marked pedestrian crosswalk. The court's ruling, issued on November 20, 2026, has significant implications for personal injury claims against police officers and their municipalities.

Background

Michael Neal filed a complaint in January 2024 against Officer Muradov, the City of Dayton, and the Dayton Police Department after he was hit by the police cruiser. Neal claimed he had the right of way while crossing the street. The City of Dayton responded by filing a motion for summary judgment, asserting that Officer Muradov was acting within the scope of his duties while responding to an emergency call at the time of the accident.

The trial court granted summary judgment in favor of the City on August 14, 2025, concluding that Officer Muradov was immune from liability because he was responding to an emergency. Neal appealed the decision, arguing that the trial court applied an improper legal standard and that reasonable minds could differ on whether Muradov was indeed responding to an emergency call.

The Ruling

The Ohio Court of Appeals, led by Judge Michael L. Tucker, upheld the trial court's decision. The court stated, "Officer Muradov was responding to an 'emergency call' when he accidentally struck Plaintiff, as set forth in R.C. 2744.01." The court emphasized that the determination of whether an officer was responding to an emergency call is a question of law, not fact.

The court reviewed the undisputed facts, noting that Officer Muradov was on routine patrol when he received a dispatch about a potential breaking and entering incident. Although he did not activate his lights or siren, the court found that his decision to respond was based on his professional obligation as a police officer. The ruling concluded that the City of Dayton was therefore immune from Neal's claims.

Impact

This ruling has significant implications for similar personal injury cases involving police officers. It reinforces the legal principle that police officers may be granted immunity from liability when responding to emergency calls, even if their response does not involve the use of lights or sirens. The court's decision clarifies the standards under which police officers operate and the extent of their liability in such situations.

Individuals injured in accidents involving police vehicles may find it more challenging to pursue claims against municipalities, as this case sets a precedent for the application of immunity under Ohio law. The ruling emphasizes the importance of the context in which police officers operate and the legal protections afforded to them while performing their duties.

What's Next

Details were not available in the court filing regarding any potential for appeal. However, the ruling may influence future cases involving police liability and emergency response situations in Ohio.