The Ohio Court of Appeals recently reversed a lower court's ruling in a legal malpractice case involving VineBrook Homes, LLC, and its former attorney, Laurence Lasky. The court's decision, issued on November 20, 2026, affects VineBrook's claims against Lasky regarding his handling of an eviction case that led to significant complications for the property management company.

This case matters because it highlights the responsibilities of attorneys in managing clients' legal matters, particularly when bankruptcy issues arise. VineBrook Homes, which manages rental properties, sought to hold Lasky accountable for alleged malpractice during an eviction process that became complicated by a tenant's bankruptcy filing.

Background

The parties involved in the case are VineBrook Homes, LLC, and NREA VB III, LLC, collectively referred to as VineBrook, and their former attorney, Laurence Lasky, along with his law firm, Lasky & Sharrer. The dispute centers around a legal malpractice claim filed by VineBrook against Lasky, alleging that his handling of an eviction case was negligent.

The dispute began when VineBrook filed a forcible entry and detainer action against tenants Dana Steele and David Luttrell for non-payment of rent. Complications arose when the City of Dayton declared the property a public nuisance due to drug violations. VineBrook sought to evict the tenants, but the situation escalated when Steele filed for bankruptcy just before the scheduled eviction date. This filing complicated the eviction process and led to the legal malpractice claim against Lasky, who represented VineBrook throughout the proceedings.

The case reached the Ohio Court of Appeals after the Montgomery County Court of Common Pleas granted summary judgment in favor of Lasky, effectively dismissing VineBrook's claims. VineBrook subsequently appealed, arguing that the trial court erred in its decision.

The Ruling

The Ohio Court of Appeals ruled in favor of VineBrook, reversing the trial court's summary judgment. The court found that the lower court had erred by granting summary judgment without properly considering the evidence and arguments presented by VineBrook. Judge Christopher B. Epley stated, "the trial court erred in granting summary judgment to Lasky based on VineBrook’s failure to present evidence regarding the standard of care."

The court emphasized that VineBrook had not been given a fair opportunity to present its case against Lasky, particularly regarding the need for expert testimony to establish the standard of care in legal malpractice claims. The ruling also noted that Lasky had not met his initial burden to demonstrate that he had acted within the standard of care required of attorneys in similar situations.

Impact

This ruling has significant implications for both VineBrook and Lasky. For VineBrook, it means that their legal malpractice claim will proceed, allowing them to potentially recover damages related to the alleged negligence of their former attorney. The case underscores the importance of attorneys adequately informing their clients about potential legal risks, especially in complex situations involving bankruptcy.

Moreover, the ruling could set a precedent for how courts handle legal malpractice claims, particularly in cases where an attorney's actions may have exposed a client to additional legal liabilities. It emphasizes that the burden of proof lies with the attorney to demonstrate that their actions were within the accepted standard of care.

What's Next

The case has been remanded to the lower court for further proceedings, meaning that VineBrook's claims against Lasky will be reconsidered. It is unclear if Lasky will appeal this decision or if there are related cases pending. However, the appellate court's ruling opens the door for VineBrook to present its case in full, potentially leading to a trial.