The Second Circuit Court of Appeals recently ruled on a significant case involving two brothers, Kaid and Fayiz Zokari, who challenged the U.S. government's authority to remove them to Yemen. The court's decision affects their claims of U.S. citizenship and has implications for similar immigration cases.

The brothers, who were born in Yemen, argued that they were U.S. citizens through their father, who became a citizen in 1979. Their legal battle began after they were arrested by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) in 2016. The brothers claimed they did not realize they were U.S. citizens at the time of their arrests and sought to terminate their removal proceedings based on their citizenship status.

The case, Alzokari v. Mullin, was filed in the Second Circuit under docket number 24-3196. The district court had previously dismissed the brothers' claims for lack of subject matter jurisdiction and failure to state a claim. The Zokari brothers appealed this decision, seeking to challenge the government's actions regarding their citizenship.

Background

Kaid and Fayiz Zokari filed their initial applications for naturalization in 2011, mistakenly believing they were not U.S. citizens. After their applications were denied, they faced removal proceedings due to convictions related to food stamp fraud. During these proceedings, they contended they were U.S. citizens through their father, who had lived in the U.S. for over ten years before their births.

In 2018, despite their pending applications for citizenship, an immigration judge ruled against them, stating that the government did not recognize them as citizens. Their removal proceedings continued until 2024 when an immigration judge granted their motions to terminate the proceedings after they established a prima facie case for citizenship.

However, the brothers continued their legal battle, seeking to challenge the denials of their applications for citizenship certificates through the Administrative Procedure Act (APA). The district court dismissed their claims, leading to the appeal to the Second Circuit.

The Ruling

The Second Circuit affirmed the district court's dismissal of the Zokari brothers' claims under the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA) but vacated the dismissal of their APA claims. The court ruled that the brothers could not pursue their INA claims because the issue of their citizenship was already in question during the removal proceedings.

The court stated, "The action was therefore barred by Section 1503(a)(2)." This ruling highlights the limitations imposed by the INA on individuals seeking to declare their citizenship while removal proceedings are ongoing.

However, the court found that the district court erred in dismissing the brothers' APA claims, stating, "We hold that the brothers were entitled to bring suit under the APA to challenge the agency action." This ruling allows the Zokari brothers to continue their pursuit of citizenship through the APA, which provides a framework for challenging agency decisions.

Impact

This ruling has significant implications for the Zokari brothers and others in similar situations. By allowing the APA claims to proceed, the court opens a pathway for individuals who have faced similar challenges in asserting their citizenship rights. The decision clarifies the relationship between the INA and the APA, particularly regarding judicial review of agency actions related to citizenship.

The court's ruling reinforces the notion that individuals may seek judicial review under the APA even when other avenues, such as the INA, may not provide a clear path for relief. This could set a precedent for future cases involving citizenship claims and immigration proceedings.

What's Next

The Zokari brothers' case will now return to the district court for further proceedings regarding their APA claims. It remains to be seen how the court will address these claims and what impact this will have on the brothers' immigration status. The brothers may also explore additional legal options depending on the outcomes of their claims under the APA.