The Ohio Court of Appeals recently vacated a ruling in a case between the Greater Dayton Regional Transit Authority (RTA) and the Amalgamated Transit Union, AFL-CIO, Local 1385. This case, docketed under numbers 30360 and 30650, centers around labor relations and the enforcement of collective bargaining agreements (CBAs). The court's decision has implications for public employers and unions in Ohio, particularly concerning arbitration and subcontracting issues.

The dispute began when the Union sought to enforce an arbitration award that required RTA to cease subcontracting certain services. The court's ruling is significant as it addresses the jurisdiction of trial courts in enforcing arbitration awards and the interpretation of collective bargaining agreements.

Background

The Greater Dayton Regional Transit Authority is a public employer that provides transportation services in the Greater Dayton area. The Amalgamated Transit Union, AFL-CIO, Local 1385 represents the employees of RTA, including bus operators and other staff. The two parties have a history of collective bargaining agreements, with the most relevant being the agreement in effect from April 1, 2016, to March 31, 2019.

This agreement included provisions for a grievance and arbitration process to resolve disputes regarding its terms. In 2017, the Union initiated arbitration over RTA’s decision to subcontract Project Mobility Paratransit Service (PMOB) to third-party vendors. The arbitrator ruled in favor of the Union, stating that RTA had violated the CBA by failing to provide written notice before subcontracting these services.

After the arbitration award was confirmed by the trial court in July 2018, the CBA expired in March 2019, and a new agreement covering the period from March 31, 2019, to April 2, 2022, was ratified in January 2020. This new agreement allowed RTA to subcontract PMOB services under certain conditions. However, the Union alleged that RTA continued to subcontract these services without proper notice, leading to the current legal dispute.

The Ruling

The Ohio Court of Appeals, led by Judge Robert G. Hanseman, ruled on November 20, 2026, that the judgments of the trial court were vacated. The court found that the trial court lacked subject matter jurisdiction to determine whether RTA had violated the confirmed arbitration award.

The court stated, "The trial court lacked jurisdiction to evaluate the Union’s claims of post-arbitration award violations, as discussed further below, as a matter of law, the trial court erred in awarding damages to the Union for alleged subcontracting violations that occurred from March 31, 2019, onward."

The court emphasized that while it had the authority to enforce arbitration awards, it could not interpret the CBA to determine if RTA had violated it. The court noted that both CBAs contained mandatory arbitration clauses, which required disputes to be submitted to arbitration rather than resolved in court.

Impact

This ruling has significant implications for labor relations in Ohio, particularly for public employers and unions. By vacating the trial court's judgment, the appeals court reinforced the importance of arbitration in resolving disputes arising from collective bargaining agreements. The decision clarifies that trial courts cannot interpret CBAs or award damages for violations that should be arbitrated.

The ruling also highlights the necessity for unions and employers to adhere to the grievance and arbitration processes outlined in their agreements. This case serves as a reminder that disputes over labor contracts must be handled according to the established procedures, ensuring that both parties have a fair opportunity to resolve their differences through arbitration.

What's Next

Following this ruling, the Union may seek to reinitiate arbitration proceedings regarding the alleged violations of the CBA. The court's decision does not preclude the Union from pursuing its claims; it simply requires that such claims be addressed through the arbitration process as stipulated in the agreements. Details regarding any further appeals or related cases were not available in the court filing.