A New Jersey court has ruled against Dominic R. Berry, a former firefighter, in his appeal regarding disability retirement benefits. The New Jersey Superior Court Appellate Division denied Berry's request to reopen his applications for ordinary disability retirement benefits (ODRB) and accidental disability retirement benefits (ADRB). This decision affects Berry's ability to receive retirement benefits after his employment with the Atlantic City Fire Department (ACFD) ended in 2018.
The court's ruling, issued on November 20, 2026, confirms that Berry did not meet the necessary requirements to qualify for the benefits he sought. The court's decision is significant as it underscores the importance of adhering to procedural requirements for retirement benefits applications.
Background
The parties involved in this case are Dominic R. Berry, the petitioner-appellant, and the Board of Trustees of the Police and Firemen's Retirement System (PFRS), the respondent-respondent. Berry had served as a firefighter with the ACFD since 2008 after his time in the Army Reserve. He faced various health challenges, including post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), migraines, and headaches, which he attributed to his military and firefighting experiences.
After experiencing a traumatic incident in 2018, Berry entered inpatient treatment for PTSD. Following his treatment, he was informed by Chief Scott Evans of the ACFD that he could not return to work and was deemed retired. Berry's resignation was effective June 30, 2018, and he subsequently filed a retirement application seeking ODRB, citing PTSD as the disabling condition.
However, Berry's application was closed by the Division of Pensions and Benefits due to his failure to submit required documentation. He later filed a second application for ADRB in October 2019, which was also closed because he was not considered a member in service at the time of the application. After several attempts to revive his applications, Berry appealed to the Board, which ultimately denied his requests.
The Ruling
The New Jersey Superior Court Appellate Division upheld the Board's decision to deny Berry's applications for ODRB and ADRB. The court found that Berry did not demonstrate good cause or reasonable diligence to warrant reopening his applications. The judges emphasized that the Board's decision was not arbitrary, capricious, or unreasonable.
The court stated, "The record is clear the FAD satisfies each of the Stallworth inquiries. The Board followed the governing law, relied on substantial credible evidence in the record, and reasonably applied the pertinent pension statutes and regulations to the facts presented."
Berry's argument that he misunderstood the retirement process was also dismissed by the court. The judges noted that the Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) found Berry had received multiple notices requesting documentation and had failed to comply with those requests. The court affirmed that Berry did not act with reasonable diligence in pursuing his applications.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for Berry and others in similar situations. It highlights the importance of adhering to procedural requirements when applying for disability retirement benefits. The court's decision reinforces the necessity for applicants to provide required documentation within specified timeframes to avoid having their applications closed.
Furthermore, the ruling sets a precedent for future cases involving disability retirement applications, emphasizing that applicants bear the burden of proof to demonstrate compliance with the necessary requirements. This case serves as a reminder that misunderstandings or delays in submitting documentation can lead to the denial of benefits.
What's Next
Berry's options for appeal are limited, as the court's decision is final. Details regarding any related cases or potential future actions by Berry were not available in the court filing. The outcome of this case may prompt Berry or others to seek further legal advice regarding their rights and options in similar circumstances.
Read Next
Court rules on New Jersey school segregation lawsuit
Court affirms dismissal of slip and fall case against hospital
Court reverses workers' compensation ruling in Deleon case
Kentucky Court Affirms Ruling in Property Dispute Case
Alabama court terminates parental rights in custody case
Ohio court affirms denial of domestic violence protection order










