A New Jersey appellate court has upheld a lower court's dismissal of a slip and fall lawsuit filed by Joshua Duffy against Trinitas Regional Medical Center. The court's decision, made on November 20, 2026, came after a jury found that Duffy failed to prove the hospital was negligent in maintaining a curb ramp where he fell and sustained a serious ankle injury.

The case, Docket No. A-1131-24, stems from an incident that occurred in October 2019 when Duffy, a taxi driver, was picking up a patient at the hospital's emergency department. Duffy alleged he slipped on a curb ramp that he claimed was defective and improperly maintained. The jury's verdict in favor of Trinitas effectively dismissed Duffy's claims for compensatory and punitive damages.

This ruling is significant as it highlights the challenges plaintiffs face in proving negligence in slip and fall cases, particularly in establishing that a property owner failed to meet safety standards. Duffy's case also illustrates the complexities involved in legal proceedings, especially regarding the admissibility of evidence and jury instructions.

Background

Joshua Duffy was the plaintiff in this case, alleging that Trinitas Regional Medical Center was negligent in maintaining a curb ramp that he claims caused his slip and fall injury. Duffy's original complaint was filed in October 2019, claiming he was a lawful business invitee at the hospital when the incident occurred. He sought damages for his injuries, including a trimalleolar ankle fracture.

Initially, Duffy's complaint included Crothall Healthcare, Inc., the property manager, as a defendant. However, Crothall was dismissed from the case in January 2022, prior to the trial. The trial itself took place over four days, during which Duffy presented evidence and witnesses to support his claims against Trinitas.

The case was marked by several pre-trial motions, including requests to use demonstrative aids and to bar certain evidence. Duffy's legal team sought to introduce a 3D model of the ramp and expert testimony regarding safety standards, but many of these requests were denied by the court.

The Ruling

The appellate court affirmed the trial court's decision, which had dismissed Duffy's complaint with prejudice. The jury found that Duffy did not prove that Trinitas was negligent in the design or maintenance of the curb ramp. The court noted that Duffy's claims hinged on the application of the American National Standards Institute (ANSI) A117.1 standards, which govern accessible construction.

The court ruled, "A jury verdict is entitled to considerable deference and should not be overthrown except upon the basis of a carefully reasoned and factually supported determination... that the continued viability of the judgment would constitute a manifest denial of justice."

The judges involved in the ruling were Firko and Bergman, who reviewed the case for procedural and evidentiary errors claimed by Duffy. The court found no abuse of discretion in the trial court's decisions regarding evidence and jury instructions.

Impact

This ruling has implications for future slip and fall cases in New Jersey, particularly those involving claims of negligence against property owners. The court's affirmation of the jury's verdict underscores the importance of presenting compelling evidence to establish negligence. It also highlights the challenges plaintiffs may face when attempting to introduce expert testimony and demonstrative evidence during trial.

Moreover, the decision reinforces the idea that a jury's verdict will be upheld unless there is clear evidence of a miscarriage of justice. This case serves as a reminder for plaintiffs to thoroughly prepare their cases and ensure that all evidence is properly disclosed and admissible.

What's Next

While Duffy's options for appeal may be limited following this ruling, there is a possibility that he could seek further review or clarification from the New Jersey Supreme Court. However, the court filing did not indicate any related cases pending or additional actions planned by the parties involved.