In a recent ruling, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit affirmed the Department of the Navy's actions against electronics engineer Mohammad Khaghani. The court's decision, issued on November 20, 2026, came after Khaghani claimed he faced retaliation for whistleblower disclosures. This ruling is significant as it highlights the challenges employees face when alleging retaliation for reporting misconduct.
Khaghani, who works at the Naval Oceanographic Office in Bay St. Louis, Mississippi, alleged that he made several protected disclosures regarding operational security violations and financial irregularities. His claims included reports of unauthorized access to Navy computer systems and instances of time and attendance fraud by his colleagues. After filing a complaint with the Office of Special Counsel in August 2022, which was later closed, Khaghani appealed to the Merit Systems Protection Board (MSPB) in August 2023. The MSPB ruled against him, leading to his appeal to the Federal Circuit.
The court's decision stems from Khaghani's allegations that the Navy retaliated against him by not selecting him for two job positions, denying him training opportunities, and changing his working conditions. The MSPB initially found that while Khaghani had made some protected disclosures, the Navy provided clear evidence that it would have taken the same actions regardless of those disclosures. This finding was a critical factor in the court's ruling.
In its ruling, the Federal Circuit stated, "The Board reasonably found that the Department would have taken the same personnel actions in the absence of Mr. Khaghani’s protected disclosures." The judges emphasized that the burden of proof lies with the petitioner, and in this case, Khaghani did not meet that burden. The court also noted that the Navy had legitimate reasons for its actions, including Khaghani's failure to submit complete applications for the job positions and his lack of progress in the training program.
The court's opinion highlighted the complexities of proving retaliation under the Whistleblower Protection Act. While Khaghani did establish that two of his disclosures were protected, the Navy's strong evidence supported its decision to take the actions it did. The court affirmed the MSPB's conclusion that Khaghani's claims did not demonstrate a significant change in his working conditions and that the alleged retaliatory actions did not amount to harassment.
This ruling is important not only for Khaghani but also for other federal employees who may be considering whistleblower actions. It underscores the need for strong evidence when alleging retaliation and clarifies the legal standards that must be met to prove such claims. Employees must be prepared to demonstrate that their disclosures were a significant factor in any adverse actions taken against them.
Looking ahead, this ruling may influence how federal employees approach whistleblower claims and retaliation allegations. It serves as a reminder of the legal hurdles involved and the importance of gathering substantial evidence to support such claims.
As for Khaghani, it is unclear whether he will pursue further legal action following this decision. The court's ruling is final unless he chooses to seek a rehearing or explore other legal avenues. There are no related cases pending at this time.
Read Next
Seventh Circuit Court Reverses Dismissal of Illinois Law Case
Fifth Circuit Court Vacates Injunction Against Mississippi Law
Fifth Circuit Court Rules on Discrimination Case at UT Austin
New York attorney publicly censured for conduct at protest
NY Court Rules on Child Neglect Case Involving Firearm
New York court affirms ruling on child abuse case involving D.C.










