The U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit has upheld the Navy's decision to deny a veteran's nomination for the Navy and Marine Corps Medal. Nicholas Voegeli, who saved a drowning student in 1992, challenged the Navy's refusal to award him the medal due to insufficient eyewitness testimony. This ruling affects veterans seeking recognition for acts of heroism and highlights the stringent requirements for military awards.

The case, Nicholas Voegeli v. Hung Cao, was decided on November 20, 2026, and centers around the Navy's policy requiring two eyewitness statements to support a medal nomination. Voegeli's situation raises questions about how military honors are awarded, especially when evidence from the time of the act may no longer be available.

Background

Nicholas Voegeli served as a Lieutenant in the Navy Reserve while studying at the University of Wisconsin-Madison in 1992. During that summer, he saved a student from drowning after their sailing boat capsized. His quick actions earned him a Coast Guard Public Service Commendation, but he believed he had missed the opportunity to be nominated for the Navy and Marine Corps Medal.

Years later, in 2018, after learning that other veterans had successfully received awards long after their heroic actions, Voegeli sought assistance from Wisconsin Senator Ron Johnson. The senator's office contacted the Navy to evaluate Voegeli's eligibility for the Navy and Marine Corps Medal. However, the Navy's Office of the Chief of Naval Operations denied his nomination, stating that it lacked the required eyewitness statements.

The Ruling

The D.C. Circuit Court reviewed the case and affirmed the lower court's decision to grant summary judgment in favor of the Navy. The court acknowledged Voegeli's bravery but emphasized that the Navy's decision was not arbitrary or capricious under the Administrative Procedure Act.

The court ruled, "Though those materials provide reason to believe that Voegeli deserves our great admiration, it was reasonable for the Board to conclude that they do not satisfy the evidentiary requirements for the award."

The ruling was delivered by Circuit Judge Walker, with Senior Circuit Judge Edwards concurring. The court noted that the Navy's policy requires two eyewitness statements to substantiate a nomination for the Navy and Marine Corps Medal, and Voegeli's submission did not meet this criterion.

Impact

This ruling has significant implications for veterans seeking military awards for acts of heroism. It underscores the importance of meeting the specific evidentiary requirements set by the Navy and highlights the challenges faced by veterans when documentation from their heroic acts is no longer available.

The court's decision reinforces the Navy's policy that eyewitness accounts are essential for medal nominations. As a result, this case may deter other veterans from pursuing similar claims if they cannot provide the necessary evidence. The ruling also serves as a reminder of the stringent standards applied to military awards, which could impact future cases involving similar circumstances.

What's Next

Details were not available in the court filing regarding whether Voegeli plans to appeal the decision. There may also be related cases pending that address similar issues regarding military awards and the evidentiary requirements for nominations.