Sally Eagleman’s case against NaphCare, Inc. is back on track after the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals reversed a lower court’s decision that had granted summary judgment to the company. The ruling, issued on November 20, 2026, allows Eagleman to pursue her claims of disability discrimination, failure to accommodate, retaliation, and failure to engage in the interactive process under California’s Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA).
This decision is significant as it highlights the responsibilities of employers in accommodating employees with disabilities and the legal protections available to those employees. The case underscores the importance of fair treatment in the workplace, particularly for individuals facing health challenges.
Background
Sally Eagleman filed her lawsuit against NaphCare, Inc., an Alabama stock corporation, after she was terminated from her position. Eagleman claimed that her dismissal was due to her disability, which she had disclosed to her employer. The dispute centers around whether NaphCare adequately accommodated her needs and whether her termination was justified.
The case reached the Ninth Circuit after the United States District Court for the Central District of California granted summary judgment in favor of NaphCare, effectively dismissing Eagleman’s claims without a trial. Eagleman appealed this decision, arguing that there were genuine disputes of material fact that warranted further examination in court.
The Ruling
The Ninth Circuit ruled in favor of Eagleman, reversing the lower court's decision. The court found that the district court had erred in its judgment regarding Eagleman’s claims. Specifically, the court stated, "Viewed in the light most favorable to Eagleman, the record evidence creates a genuine dispute of material fact over whether she could have performed the essential functions of her job with a reasonable accommodation."
The judges emphasized that Eagleman had provided evidence of her need for additional time off due to her disability and that NaphCare’s response to her requests was inadequate. The ruling noted that Eagleman had demonstrated her willingness to return to work and had communicated her needs to the company, which should have prompted a more thorough consideration of her situation.
Additionally, the court pointed out that Eagleman’s claims of failure to accommodate and retaliation also presented triable issues of fact. The judges clarified that the elements of retaliation under FEHA differ from those of discrimination, which the district court had conflated. This distinction is crucial as it emphasizes the protections available to employees who request accommodations for their disabilities.
Impact
The Ninth Circuit’s decision has significant implications for both Eagleman and other employees facing similar situations. It reinforces the legal obligation of employers to engage in a meaningful dialogue with employees about their accommodation requests. This ruling sends a clear message that employers must take their employees’ needs seriously and cannot simply dismiss requests for accommodations without proper consideration.
Moreover, the case could set a precedent for how courts interpret the requirements for employers under FEHA, particularly regarding disability discrimination and the interactive process. Employees may feel more empowered to assert their rights knowing that the courts are willing to scrutinize employer actions closely.
What’s Next
The case will return to the district court for further proceedings. Eagleman’s claims for punitive damages and issues related to judicial estoppel will also be addressed on remand. It remains to be seen how the district court will handle these claims, but the Ninth Circuit’s ruling has opened the door for Eagleman to present her case fully.
Read Next
Ninth Circuit affirms denial of default judgment in FCA case
Ninth Circuit upholds bankruptcy court's corrected judgment
Ninth Circuit denies asylum for Dos Santos and child
Seventh Circuit upholds dismissal of Hsieh's privacy claim
Court reverses lower ruling on Illinois nonprofit law case
Ninth Circuit Affirms Denial of Johnson's Appeal in Housing Case










