The California Court of Appeal has reversed a ruling that reappointed the Public Guardian of Los Angeles as conservator for W.W., a 54-year-old woman. The court found that there was insufficient evidence to support the trial court's determination that W.W. was gravely disabled due to a mental disorder. This decision affects W.W. directly, as it challenges the legal basis for her conservatorship, which has been in place since 2017.

The case, titled Conservatorship of W.W., was filed under docket number B351160. The ruling was issued on November 20, 2026, and it highlights the importance of proper evidentiary support in conservatorship cases, particularly those involving mental health issues.

W.W. had been under conservatorship since October 2017, with annual reestablishments occurring each year. In August 2025, the Public Guardian filed a petition to reestablish the conservatorship. During a hearing in September 2025, W.W.'s stand-in counsel indicated that she had refused to participate in the proceedings and claimed she was not under conservatorship. This prompted the court to set a trial to address her refusal.

On November 12, 2025, before the trial commenced, an employee from W.W.'s residential facility informed the court that W.W. was refusing to attend. The employee stated that W.W. denied having a conservator, but did not discuss the conservatorship itself. The court then proceeded with the trial in W.W.'s absence, allowing a forensic psychologist, Marion Arom, to testify as an expert witness.

Arom testified that W.W. had not spoken to her for three consecutive years and based her opinion on W.W.'s residential chart, which was not admitted into evidence. The court allowed Arom to provide her opinion but instructed her not to reveal the contents of the chart. Arom stated, "I have only information from the chart. I never testify from the chart because it’s hearsay. But I don’t have anything else to testify from." Despite this, the court accepted Arom's opinion, concluding that W.W. was gravely disabled.

The court's decision to rely on Arom's testimony raised significant legal concerns. The court ruled that Arom's opinion lacked substantial evidentiary support since it was based solely on hearsay from W.W.'s residential chart, which was not admitted into evidence. The court noted that the Public Guardian did not produce the chart or provide any other evidence to support the claim of W.W.'s grave disability.

The ruling emphasized the importance of proper evidentiary standards in conservatorship cases, particularly under the Lanterman-Petris-Short (LPS) Act, which governs such proceedings in California. The court stated, "A judgment based solely on an expert opinion that relied on such assumptions and factors must be reversed for lack of substantial evidence." This ruling underscores the necessity for courts to ensure that any findings of grave disability are supported by credible and admissible evidence.

The impact of this ruling is significant for W.W. and others in similar situations. It sets a precedent that reinforces the requirement for substantial evidence in conservatorship cases. The court's decision highlights the need for strict adherence to evidentiary standards to protect the rights of individuals facing conservatorship. Moving forward, this ruling may influence how conservatorship cases are handled in California, ensuring that individuals are not subjected to conservatorship without adequate legal justification.

In terms of next steps, the Public Guardian may still file a new petition to reestablish conservatorship for W.W. if deemed necessary. The court's reversal does not prevent future proceedings regarding W.W.'s conservatorship status. The ruling allows for the possibility of a new trial or hearing if the Public Guardian presents sufficient evidence to support a new petition.