In a significant ruling for local businesses, the Ohio Court of Appeals addressed the dispute between Erie Island Carts, LLC, and the Village of Put-in-Bay regarding a controversial golf cart rental fee. The court's decision, issued on November 20, 2026, partially favored Erie Island, affirming some claims while dismissing others. This case highlights the ongoing tension between local governments and businesses operating outside their jurisdiction.
The court's ruling affects Erie Island Carts and Island Bike Rental, both of which operate outside the village limits but were subjected to a new ordinance requiring them to pay a vehicle license fee to the village. The outcome of this case is crucial for similar businesses that may face similar regulations in the future.
Background
Erie Island Carts, LLC, and Island Bike Rental, LLC, are two golf cart rental businesses located in Put-in-Bay Township, outside the jurisdiction of the Village of Put-in-Bay. The village, a popular tourist destination on South Bass Island in Ottawa County, has long struggled with traffic congestion and pedestrian safety due to the influx of visitors. In response, the village passed an ordinance requiring businesses that rent vehicles within its limits to pay an annual nontransferable vehicle license fee.
This ordinance, known as C.O. 858.01, was previously upheld by the Ohio Supreme Court in a case involving another golf cart rental business within the village. However, in May 2024, the village expanded this ordinance to include businesses operating outside its limits, prompting Erie Island to file a lawsuit. The village claimed that these businesses must comply with the new fee structure, which they argued was a legitimate exercise of the village's home rule authority.
The Ruling
The Ohio Court of Appeals, led by Judge Sulek, ruled on several counts within Erie Island's complaint. The court affirmed the dismissal of some claims while allowing others to proceed. Specifically, the court found that the trial court had subject matter jurisdiction over Erie Island's claims for declaratory judgment regarding the constitutionality of the ordinance. The court stated, "R.C. Chapter 2723 does not prevent Erie Island from pursuing a declaratory judgment that the Village’s ordinance is unconstitutional." This indicates that the court recognized the potential for the ordinance to exceed the village's taxing authority.
However, the court also upheld the dismissal of Erie Island's claims for the recovery of fees paid in 2024, stating that they did not comply with the statutory requirements for challenging the tax. The court noted, "The written protest and notice of intention to sue provisions of R.C. 2723.03 are mandatory and must be strictly adhered to if an action for the recovery of allegedly wrongfully collected taxes is to be maintained." This ruling emphasizes the importance of following proper legal procedures when contesting tax assessments.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for Erie Island and other businesses operating in similar circumstances. By allowing the claims for declaratory judgment to proceed, the court opens the door for a potential challenge to the village's authority to impose fees on businesses located outside its jurisdiction. If the ordinance is ultimately found unconstitutional, it could set a precedent that limits local governments' ability to tax businesses operating beyond their borders.
Moreover, the decision underscores the necessity for businesses to be aware of local regulations and the importance of adhering to statutory requirements when contesting fees. The court's ruling may encourage other businesses to challenge similar ordinances if they believe their rights are being infringed upon.
What's Next
Following this ruling, Erie Island may continue to pursue its claims regarding the constitutionality of the ordinance and seek relief from the imposed fees. The Village of Put-in-Bay may also consider appealing the court's decision, particularly regarding the claims that were allowed to proceed. The outcome of this case could influence future regulations affecting businesses in tourist areas and beyond.
Read Next
Ohio Court upholds summary judgment in police injury case
Ohio Court upholds dismissal of firearm charges against teen
Ohio court affirms denial of domestic violence protection order
Alabama Supreme Court dismisses appeal in construction case
Court rules against Insight Public Sector in bid protest
Fifth Circuit affirms dismissal of Cuevas Machine's lien case










