The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has denied an asylum petition filed by Sandra Eliza Salazar-De Arias and her three children. The court ruled that the family failed to provide sufficient evidence to support their claims of past persecution or a well-founded fear of future persecution. This decision affects the family’s ability to remain in the United States and highlights the challenges many face in seeking asylum.
The ruling came on November 20, 2026, as the court reviewed an order from the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) that had dismissed the family's appeal. The court's decision is significant as it underscores the stringent requirements for asylum seekers to establish their claims.
Background
In this case, Sandra Eliza Salazar-De Arias, along with her children C. S. A.-S., D. I. A.-S., and E. D. A.-S., sought asylum in the United States after fleeing El Salvador. They claimed they faced persecution due to their membership in a particular social group of “single women in El Salvador and their children who cooperate with government officials against criminal activity.”
The family’s appeal stemmed from a prior decision by an Immigration Judge (IJ) who denied their applications for asylum, withholding of removal, and protection under the Convention Against Torture (CAT). The family argued that they were at risk of extortion and violence due to their cooperation with authorities against criminal gangs in their home country.
The case was brought before the Ninth Circuit after the BIA dismissed their appeal. The court's review focused on whether substantial evidence supported the BIA's findings regarding the family's claims.
The Ruling
The Ninth Circuit ruled against the family, stating that substantial evidence supported the BIA's denial of their applications for asylum and withholding of removal. The court noted that the family did not demonstrate past persecution or a well-founded fear of future persecution based on a protected ground.
The court stated, “Substantial evidence supports the denial of Petitioners’ applications for asylum and withholding of removal based on their failure to establish past persecution or a well-founded fear of future persecution on account of a protected ground.”
The court also explained that the proposed social group was not considered socially distinct within Salvadoran society. The BIA had determined that there was no evidence showing that individuals who cooperate with authorities against criminal activity are viewed as a distinct group in El Salvador.
Furthermore, the court found that the family failed to satisfy the nexus requirement, which means they could not show a direct link between their fear of persecution and a protected ground. The court cited a previous ruling, stating that economic extortion could be considered persecution only if it is motivated by a protected ground.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for asylum seekers from El Salvador and other countries facing similar circumstances. It emphasizes the high burden of proof required for applicants to establish their claims for asylum. The decision may discourage other potential applicants who fear persecution but struggle to provide the necessary evidence to support their claims.
The court's ruling also reinforces the requirement for a proposed social group to be recognized as distinct within the society in question. This aspect of the ruling could impact future cases involving claims based on social group membership, as it sets a precedent for how courts evaluate such claims.
What's Next
The family has the option to appeal this decision, but details about any potential appeal were not available in the court filing. As of now, there are no related cases pending that directly connect to this ruling.
Read Next
Ninth Circuit denies asylum for Dos Santos and child
Ninth Circuit affirms ruling on insurance coverage dispute
Ninth Circuit grants qualified immunity to prison doctors
Court denies asylum request for Honduran man in New York
Court denies asylum appeal for Albanian family in New York
Second Circuit Court Rules on Zokari Brothers' Citizenship Case










