In a recent ruling, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals dismissed an appeal from Juan Calmo-Pablo, a native of Guatemala, who sought asylum in the United States. The court found that Calmo-Pablo did not sufficiently demonstrate a credible threat of persecution or torture if he were to be returned to Guatemala. This decision affects Calmo-Pablo's hopes of staying in the U.S. and highlights the challenges many immigrants face when seeking asylum.
The case, filed under docket number 24-5352, arose from Calmo-Pablo's petition for review of a decision made by the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA). The BIA had previously dismissed his appeal from an Immigration Judge's (IJ) order that denied him withholding of removal and protection under the Convention Against Torture (CAT). This ruling is significant as it underscores the stringent requirements for asylum seekers to prove their claims.
Juan Calmo-Pablo, who identifies as indigenous, argued that he faced threats from gang members in Guatemala. He claimed that these threats were tied to his ethnic identity and his opposition to gang activities. However, the BIA determined that he did not establish a clear connection between his fears and his indigenous identity. The court noted that Calmo-Pablo could not explain why he was targeted by gang members, stating, "I don’t know how to explain why" when asked about the motivations behind the gang's actions.
The BIA also evaluated Calmo-Pablo's proposed particular social group (PSG), which he defined as "indigenous Guatemalans from Huehuetenango who oppose gangs." The BIA found this group to be non-cognizable, meaning it did not meet the legal criteria for a valid PSG. According to the BIA, the characteristic of opposing gangs was too vague and subjective to qualify.
In its ruling, the Ninth Circuit upheld the BIA's findings, stating that substantial evidence supported the conclusion that Calmo-Pablo did not demonstrate a credible fear of persecution. The court emphasized that to qualify for withholding of removal, a non-citizen must show that it is "more likely than not" that their life or freedom would be threatened based on specific factors such as race, religion, nationality, or political opinion.
Furthermore, the court assessed Calmo-Pablo's claim for relief under the Convention Against Torture. To succeed in this claim, an applicant must prove that it is more likely than not that they will be tortured if removed to their home country. The court found that the evidence presented did not support Calmo-Pablo's assertion of past torture. He testified that he only sustained a bump on his head from a gang assault and did not seek medical treatment, which the court deemed insufficient to meet the definition of torture.
The court's opinion stated, "Substantial evidence supports the BIA’s finding that the assault by the gang was not severe enough to count as torture." Additionally, the BIA concluded that any potential future torture would not be inflicted by public officials or with their consent, further weakening Calmo-Pablo's case.
As a result of this ruling, Calmo-Pablo's petition for review was denied, meaning he will face removal proceedings and may be sent back to Guatemala. This decision is crucial for other asylum seekers who may face similar challenges in proving their claims for protection.
The impact of this ruling extends beyond Calmo-Pablo. It serves as a reminder of the rigorous standards that individuals seeking asylum in the United States must meet. The court’s decision reinforces the necessity for clear evidence linking persecution to specific characteristics recognized under U.S. immigration law.
Going forward, this ruling may influence future cases involving asylum seekers from Guatemala and other countries facing gang violence. It highlights the importance of presenting a well-documented case that establishes a clear nexus between the individual's fears and the grounds for asylum.
Details regarding whether Calmo-Pablo plans to appeal the ruling were not available in the court filing. However, it is possible for him to seek further legal recourse, depending on the circumstances surrounding his case.
Read Next
Ninth Circuit upholds dismissal of Perry employment case
Ninth Circuit affirms conviction of Monte Shepherd for firearm possession
Court denies Rosas-Arenas' appeal for immigration relief
Ninth Circuit denies asylum for Dos Santos and child
Court denies asylum request for Honduran man in New York
Court denies asylum appeal for Albanian family in New York










