The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has denied the asylum claims of Liliana Dos Santos and her minor child, M.L.D.S. The court ruled that the evidence presented did not sufficiently demonstrate past persecution or a reasonable fear of future persecution if they were to return to Angola. This decision affects the petitioners' ability to seek refuge in the United States, highlighting the challenges many face in immigration proceedings.

The ruling stems from a petition filed by Dos Santos and her child, who sought protection under U.S. asylum laws. The case was reviewed on November 18, 2026, and the court's decision was released shortly thereafter. The implications of this ruling extend beyond the individual case, as it underscores the rigorous standards required for asylum seekers in the U.S.

Background

Liliana Dos Santos and her child, M.L.D.S., sought asylum in the United States after facing threats in their home country of Angola. They claimed that Dos Santos was threatened by a member of her church due to her father's Congolese heritage. The case was initially reviewed by an immigration judge (IJ), who ultimately denied their claims. The Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) affirmed this decision, leading Dos Santos to appeal to the Ninth Circuit.

The petitioners argued that they faced persecution and that their fear of returning to Angola was justified. However, the IJ found that the evidence did not meet the legal threshold for asylum. This led to the appeal to the Ninth Circuit, where the judges reviewed the IJ's decision and the evidence presented.

The Ruling

The Ninth Circuit upheld the IJ's decision, stating that substantial evidence did not compel a finding of past persecution for Dos Santos and her child. The court noted, "Persecution is an 'extreme concept,' and not every instance of mistreatment qualifies." The judges emphasized that while credible threats can constitute persecution, the specific threat faced by Dos Santos did not rise to that level.

The court also ruled that the petitioners did not demonstrate an objectively reasonable fear of future persecution. The IJ had noted that the threat against Dos Santos was over a decade old and that there was no evidence of ongoing interest or harm from the individual who made the threat. The judges stated, "The record evidence does not compel that finding," reinforcing the IJ's conclusion that the fears expressed by Dos Santos were speculative.

Impact

This ruling has significant implications for asylum seekers, particularly those who may rely on past threats as a basis for their claims. The court's decision illustrates the high burden of proof required to establish both past persecution and a reasonable fear of future harm. It serves as a reminder that not all threats or instances of mistreatment qualify for asylum protection under U.S. law.

The ruling may also impact future cases involving similar claims, as it sets a precedent regarding the standards of evidence necessary for asylum applications. Petitioners must provide compelling evidence that demonstrates a well-founded fear of persecution, which can be a challenging threshold to meet.

What's Next

The petitioners may seek further legal options, including the possibility of appealing the decision to the U.S. Supreme Court. However, details on any related cases or pending appeals were not available in the court filing.