The Third Circuit Court of Appeals ruled against Eliana Tuyo Quispe, a citizen of Peru, affirming the denial of her motion to reopen removal proceedings. This decision impacts Quispe's ability to remain in the United States, where she has lived since 2002 and has two U.S. citizen daughters. The ruling emphasizes the challenges faced by immigrants seeking to avoid deportation based on family hardship.
Quispe entered the U.S. illegally in 2002 and later applied for cancellation of removal, arguing that her deportation would cause exceptional hardship to her daughters. The Immigration Judge (IJ) denied her application in October 2020, stating that her removal would not impose an extraordinary burden on her children. Quispe later sought to reopen her case, citing deteriorating conditions in Peru due to the COVID-19 pandemic, but her motion was denied.
The case began when the Department of Homeland Security issued a Notice to Appear in 2017, charging Quispe with entering the U.S. without proper documentation. She conceded her removability but sought cancellation of removal under 8 U.S.C. § 1229b(b)(1)(D), claiming her daughters would face exceptional hardship if forced to move to Peru. The IJ concluded that while conditions in Peru were challenging, they did not meet the legal standard for exceptional hardship.
After the IJ's initial ruling, Quispe did not appeal but instead filed a motion to reopen her case in January 2021. She argued that the COVID-19 pandemic had worsened conditions in Peru, impacting her daughters' potential adjustment to life there. The IJ denied this motion, stating that the pandemic had also negatively affected the U.S. and that the hardships faced by her daughters in Peru would not be significantly different from those they were experiencing in the U.S.
Quispe then appealed to the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) in October 2021. The BIA upheld the IJ's ruling, emphasizing that Quispe had not demonstrated how her daughters would face exceptional hardship if they were removed to Peru. The BIA noted that the IJ had adequately considered the evidence Quispe presented regarding the pandemic's impact.
The Third Circuit's ruling, issued on November 20, 2026, confirmed that both the IJ and the BIA acted within their discretion. The court stated, "The IJ and the BIA have not abused their discretion here." The court found that both bodies had meaningfully considered Quispe's arguments and evidence regarding the pandemic's impact on Peru.
The ruling underscores the high standard that petitioners must meet to reopen immigration cases based on changed country conditions. The court noted that motions to reopen are generally disfavored unless compelling circumstances are present. The court's opinion highlighted that Quispe did not provide sufficient evidence to show that her daughters would experience hardship that was substantially different from what is normally expected during deportation.
This decision is significant for individuals in similar situations, as it illustrates the challenges faced by immigrants seeking to avoid removal based on family hardship claims. The ruling sets a precedent for how courts may interpret the standards for exceptional hardship in future cases.
Looking ahead, Quispe's options appear limited. The court's ruling can be appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court, but such appeals are rare and typically require substantial legal grounds. There are currently no related cases pending that could influence Quispe's situation directly.
Read Next
Court affirms dismissal of car lease dispute against CULA
Third Circuit rules on Samsung data breach claims appeal
Court vacates ruling in Promier Products false advertising case
Ninth Circuit denies asylum for Dos Santos and child
Court denies asylum request for Honduran man in New York
Court denies asylum appeal for Albanian family in New York










