The Arizona Court of Appeals has upheld the convictions of Antonio Velazquez-Azamar for two counts of aggravated assault. This ruling, issued on November 19, 2026, affects Velazquez-Azamar, who was sentenced to a total of 10 years in prison for his actions. The decision clarifies legal interpretations regarding multiple charges stemming from a single act of violence.
In this case, Velazquez-Azamar was found guilty of using a deadly weapon and causing serious injury during an incident involving a victim identified only as Tim. The court's ruling is significant as it addresses the legal principles of double jeopardy and the definition of separate offenses under Arizona law.
Background
The case began when Tim witnessed Velazquez-Azamar arguing with a woman outside his office late at night. Concerned for the woman's safety, Tim called the police while observing the confrontation from his truck. As he attempted to leave the scene, Velazquez-Azamar threw a rock at Tim's vehicle, prompting Tim to confront him.
During this confrontation, Velazquez-Azamar attacked Tim, resulting in severe injuries. Tim suffered 12 facial fractures and long-term vision impairment due to the assault. Following a four-day trial, Velazquez-Azamar was convicted of two counts of aggravated assault under Arizona Revised Statutes Section 13-1204. The superior court sentenced him to concurrent prison terms of 7.5 years and 2.5 years for the respective counts.
The Ruling
The Court of Appeals, led by Judge Angela K. Paton, affirmed Velazquez-Azamar's convictions. The court ruled that the charges against him did not violate double jeopardy protections, which prevent an individual from being punished multiple times for the same offense. The judge stated, "Charges are multiplicitous if they charge a single offense in multiple counts," but clarified that the specific subsections under which Velazquez-Azamar was charged represent separate offenses.
In reaching its decision, the court referenced a previous ruling in State v. Kelly, which established that the subsections of Arizona's aggravated assault statute describe distinct offenses. Therefore, Velazquez-Azamar could be sentenced separately for each count, even if they arose from a single act of violence. The court concluded, "Velazquez-Azamar has not persuaded us to depart from Kelly and, therefore, his multiplicity and double jeopardy claims fail."
Impact
This ruling has important implications for future cases involving aggravated assault and similar charges in Arizona. By affirming the distinction between subsections of the aggravated assault statute, the court reinforces the idea that defendants can face separate charges for different aspects of their actions, even if those actions occur simultaneously. This could lead to harsher penalties for those convicted of multiple counts arising from a single incident.
The decision also clarifies how courts will interpret claims of double jeopardy in Arizona. Defendants may need to provide stronger arguments to prove that their charges are multiplicitous and violate their rights against being tried or punished multiple times for the same offense.
What's Next
Velazquez-Azamar has the option to appeal the ruling to a higher court, although details regarding any potential appeal were not available in the court filing. There are no related cases pending that would directly impact this decision.
Read Next
Court affirms eviction ruling in Lewis v. Avant Garde case
Court reverses summary judgment in Gutierrez v. Parra case
Arizona court vacates convictions in self-representation case
Florida Court Affirms Ruling in Harrison v. State Case
Court vacates sentence for bank robbery, orders resentencing
Court affirms conviction of Erick Collins for drug offenses










