The Arkansas Court of Appeals has upheld the conviction of Robert Asbell for committing a terroristic act after he fired shots into the home of his former girlfriend. The court's ruling, delivered on November 18, 2026, confirms Asbell's 35-year prison sentence while also addressing a clerical error in the sentencing order. This case highlights the legal implications of threats and violence in domestic relationships.

Asbell, who was convicted by a Crawford County jury, contended that the court erred by denying his motion for a directed verdict, arguing that the state did not prove he acted with the intent to cause injury or damage. The ruling is significant as it reinforces the legal standards surrounding terroristic acts and the interpretation of intent in criminal cases.

Background

Robert Asbell was charged with committing a terroristic act, attempted first-degree battery, and a firearm enhancement under Arkansas law following an incident on August 17, 2024. The charges stemmed from an event where shots were fired into the Van Buren home of his ex-girlfriend, Valerina Tompkins. The case was brought to trial after a jury found sufficient evidence to proceed against Asbell.

During the trial, which took place in September 2025, several witnesses provided testimony that painted a picture of a volatile situation. Tompkins, who had dated Asbell for approximately a year before their relationship ended in July 2024, testified about a series of threatening text messages she received from him. These messages included vulgar language and threats, contributing to her fear for her safety on the night of the shooting.

Witness Kathy Billy, a neighbor, testified that she heard multiple gunshots and saw Asbell standing outside Tompkins’s home with a handgun. Following the shooting, Tompkins discovered several bullet holes in her home, leading to the charges against Asbell. The prosecution presented evidence that included ballistic findings linking the bullets to a revolver found in Asbell's home.

The Ruling

The Arkansas Court of Appeals ruled to affirm Asbell's conviction, stating that there was sufficient evidence to support the jury's decision. The court noted, "The natural and probable consequence of firing every round in a revolver through the window of a furnished home is damage to the property inside." This statement underscores the court's view that the jury could reasonably infer Asbell's intent to cause damage.

The court also highlighted that Asbell's actions leading up to the shooting, including the threatening messages and his behavior after the incident, contributed to the jury's findings. The judges pointed out that intent is often inferred from the circumstances surrounding a crime, as direct evidence of a person's state of mind is rarely available.

Additionally, the ruling addressed a clerical error in the sentencing order, which incorrectly identified the statute under which Asbell was convicted. The court remanded the case back to the circuit court to correct this error, ensuring that the official record accurately reflects the nature of the crime committed.

Impact

This ruling has significant implications for how courts interpret intent in cases involving domestic violence and threats. By affirming the conviction, the Arkansas Court of Appeals reinforces the idea that threatening behavior, combined with actions that result in actual harm or potential harm, can lead to severe legal consequences.

The decision also serves as a precedent for future cases involving similar charges, emphasizing that juries can infer intent from the circumstances surrounding a crime. This could influence how prosecutors approach cases of domestic violence and terroristic threats in Arkansas and potentially beyond.

What's Next

Asbell has the option to appeal the ruling to a higher court, although details about any potential appeal were not available in the court filing. There are currently no related cases pending that would directly affect this ruling.