A recent ruling by the Arkansas Court of Appeals has significant implications for a child protection case involving Khalil Campbell and his former partner, Kenyatta Hayes. The court's decision affects the custody and protection of their minor twin sons, MC1 and MC2, after allegations of abuse were made against Campbell. The ruling highlights the importance of evidence in domestic abuse cases, particularly when children are involved.
Khalil Campbell appealed an order from the Pulaski County Circuit Court that prohibited him from contacting his twin sons for three years. The court found that Hayes, the children’s mother, did not provide sufficient evidence to support an order of protection for MC2, while affirming the order for MC1 and Hayes. This ruling is crucial as it addresses the standards of proof required in domestic abuse cases involving children.
Background
The case began when Kenyatta Hayes filed for an order of protection on June 5, 2025, claiming that Campbell had committed acts of violence against their children. Hayes alleged that Campbell had physically harmed the boys, including slamming MC1 into a vehicle and choking him. The petition also included accusations of beatings that left scars and the refusal of meals.
The Pulaski County Circuit Court held a hearing on August 19, 2025, where the main witness was MC1’s third-grade teacher, Kinley Ray. Ray testified that she witnessed Campbell pick up MC1 from school and later saw him holding the boy by the collar against a car, yelling at him before throwing him into the back seat. This incident raised serious concerns about Campbell's behavior and prompted Hayes to seek legal protection for her children.
During the hearing, Hayes explained that she and Campbell had a parenting plan established in Colorado, where Campbell had custody of the children. However, at the time of the incident, the boys had been living with Hayes in Little Rock for about six months. After the alleged incident, Campbell returned to Colorado, while Hayes sought to gain custody of the boys in Arkansas.
The Ruling
The Arkansas Court of Appeals ultimately reversed the order of protection as it pertained to MC2, while affirming the order for MC1 and Hayes. The court ruled that Hayes had met her burden of proof regarding the order of protection for MC1, stating, "The testimony supports the conclusion that Campbell held MC1 up by his shirt collar to the point that he lifted MC1’s feet off the ground and shook him." However, the court found no evidence that Campbell abused MC2 or that he was present during the alleged abuse.
The court emphasized that the petitioner must show abuse or fear of abuse for every individual on whose behalf the petition is filed. In this case, the court noted, "The record is devoid of any evidence that Campbell abused MC2." Therefore, they reversed the protective order concerning MC2 while affirming the protection for MC1 and Hayes.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for future domestic abuse cases, particularly those involving children. It underscores the necessity for clear evidence when seeking protective orders. The court's decision to reverse the order for MC2 serves as a reminder that allegations must be substantiated with evidence that each child is at risk or has experienced abuse.
Moreover, the court's affirmation of the order of protection for MC1 and Hayes highlights the court's recognition of the seriousness of domestic abuse and the need to protect victims. This case may set a precedent for how courts evaluate evidence in similar situations, potentially influencing future rulings in domestic violence cases involving children.
What's Next
It is unclear whether Campbell will appeal the court's decision. However, the ruling has established a clear framework regarding the need for evidence in domestic abuse cases involving children. Details regarding any related cases or future actions by either party were not available in the court filing.
Read Next
Arkansas Court Upholds Divorce Settlement Disputes
Arkansas court upholds law enforcement decertification ruling
Court affirms revocation of Randy Coaker's suspended sentence
Court upholds ruling against Fishman in disability case
Court affirms ruling in disability discrimination case
Court affirms dismissal of privacy claim against PitchBook










