The Maine Supreme Judicial Court has dismissed the appeal of Ryan P. Reardon, who sought to challenge his conviction for domestic violence assault. The court ruled that it lacked jurisdiction to hear the case because Reardon's failure to comply with court-imposed requirements was deemed excusable. This decision affects Reardon directly, as he will remain convicted of domestic violence assault, which carries significant legal consequences.
The case, State of Maine v. Ryan P. Reardon, was decided on November 19, 2026, under docket number Pis-25-93. The ruling stems from a plea agreement Reardon entered into after being charged with multiple offenses, including aggravated assault and domestic violence assault. The court's decision highlights the complexities of deferred sentencing agreements and the limitations on appeals in such cases.
Background
Ryan P. Reardon was indicted in June 2021 on charges including aggravated assault and domestic violence assault. In July 2022, he entered a plea agreement with the State of Maine, pleading guilty to domestic violence assault. The agreement stipulated that if he complied with certain conditions, he could withdraw his guilty plea and plead guilty to a lesser charge of domestic violence reckless conduct after a two-year deferment period.
During the deferment period, Reardon faced serious health issues, including knee injuries and a significant head injury that affected his cognitive abilities. As a result, he did not complete the required domestic violence intervention program or undergo a substance abuse evaluation. At the end of the deferment period, a final hearing was held, where the court found that while Reardon had failed to comply with the conditions, his noncompliance was excusable.
The Ruling
Despite finding Reardon's noncompliance excusable, the court concluded that it could not allow him to withdraw his guilty plea. The trial court relied on principles of contract interpretation, determining that Reardon's failure to meet the conditions excused the State from fulfilling its part of the plea agreement. The court stated, "Reardon failed to complete two material terms of his agreement with the State and that this material failure to perform excused the State from its obligation to effectuate the successful outcome of the agreement."
As a result, the court sentenced Reardon to ninety days in jail, with all but four days suspended, and one year of probation. Following this ruling, Reardon appealed the decision, seeking to challenge the trial court's final disposition.
Impact
The Maine Supreme Judicial Court's dismissal of Reardon's appeal underscores the limitations placed on defendants in deferred disposition cases. The court ruled that it did not have jurisdiction to entertain his appeal because he did not fall under the statutory exception that allows appeals when a defendant's failure to comply with deferment requirements is deemed inexcusably. This ruling sets a precedent regarding the interpretation of appeal rights in similar cases, emphasizing the importance of compliance with court-imposed conditions.
This decision affects not only Reardon but also future defendants in similar situations. Those who enter into deferred disposition agreements must be aware that failure to meet the conditions can lead to serious consequences, including a conviction and sentencing without the opportunity for appeal.
What's Next
Reardon cannot appeal this decision further, as the court has dismissed his appeal based on jurisdictional grounds. There are no related cases pending that could impact the outcome of this ruling. The court's decision highlights the need for clarity in the law regarding deferred dispositions and the rights of defendants.
Read Next
Maine court revives inheritance claim in family dispute
Court awards attorney fees in immigration habeas case
Maine Court Rules on Parental Rights in Religious Upbringing
Court overturns conviction, grants new trial for Jones
Washington court reverses escape conviction due to error
Court dismisses Rhashema Shackleford's appeal motion










