The Ohio Court of Appeals has upheld the convictions of Martinis Watts for two counts of rape. The court ruled that Watts' guilty plea was knowingly, intelligently, and voluntarily entered, despite his claims to the contrary. This decision affects Watts, who was sentenced to ten years in prison and must register as a sex offender.

The case, State v. Watts, was filed under docket number 116134 and involved serious allegations stemming from incidents that occurred between January and June of 1997. Watts had been charged with multiple counts of rape and kidnapping, which included specifications indicating he was a sexually violent predator. The indictment was not issued until May 2016, and Watts was not arrested until October 2023, while he was incarcerated in Florida.

Watts' legal journey began with a grand jury indictment that included four counts of rape and two counts of kidnapping. After being referred to a psychiatric clinic, he underwent a competency hearing in 2024, where it was determined that he was not competent to stand trial initially. Following treatment, he was found competent to stand trial in November 2024. However, the process was complicated by Watts' frequent requests for new attorneys and motions to disqualify his counsel.

On the day of his trial in January 2026, after expressing dissatisfaction with his legal representation, Watts ultimately entered a plea agreement. He pled guilty to two counts of rape without any specifications, acknowledging during a court colloquy that he understood the nature of the charges and the rights he was waiving by entering the plea.

On January 29, 2026, the court sentenced Watts to ten years in prison and required him to register as a sex offender. Following this, Watts filed an appeal, arguing that his plea was not entered knowingly and that he had received ineffective assistance from his trial counsel. He raised three specific assignments of error for the court's review.

The court ruled that Watts' plea was valid, stating, "A trial court does not completely fail to comply with Crim.R. 11(C)(2) so as to render a guilty plea invalid when it fails to explicitly state that a guilty plea constitutes a complete admission of guilt as long as the trial court otherwise complies with the requirements of Crim.R. 11(C)(2)." The court found that Watts had been properly informed of his rights and the consequences of his plea during the colloquy.

Additionally, the court addressed Watts' claim of ineffective assistance of counsel, stating that he failed to demonstrate that he would not have pled guilty if his attorney had raised the motions he desired. The ruling emphasized that Watts did not show a reasonable probability that he would have insisted on going to trial instead of accepting the plea deal.

In his second assignment of error, Watts argued that the trial court abused its discretion by denying his presentence motion to withdraw his guilty plea. The court noted that while such motions should be granted liberally, there is no absolute right to withdraw a plea. The court ultimately found that Watts' pro se motion was not valid since he was represented by counsel at the time.

Judge Kathleen Ann Keough authored the opinion, with Judges Emanuella D. Groves and Anita Laster Mays concurring. The court affirmed the judgment of the lower court, stating that the trial court's decisions were reasonable and supported by the record.

This ruling has significant implications for Watts, who remains incarcerated and must comply with the requirements of his sentence. It also reinforces the standards for guilty pleas in Ohio, emphasizing the importance of a thorough colloquy to ensure that defendants understand their rights and the implications of their pleas.

Looking ahead, Watts has the option to appeal the decision to a higher court, but it remains uncertain if he will pursue that route. The outcome of this case may also influence future cases involving similar claims of ineffective counsel and the validity of guilty pleas in Ohio.