The Texas Court of Appeals recently upheld the convictions of Roberto Cisneros for intoxication manslaughter and failure to stop and render aid. The court's decision, filed on November 10, 2026, confirms Cisneros' 10-year prison sentence for each charge, which will run concurrently. This ruling is significant as it addresses the complexities surrounding a defendant's right to appeal and the responsibilities of legal counsel in ensuring those rights are protected.

The case originated from a tragic incident in 2017, when Cisneros was involved in a fatal car crash that resulted in the death of Tommy Gaines. At the time of the accident, Cisneros was driving at a high speed of 69 mph in a 35 mph zone and had a blood alcohol content of .166, well above the legal limit. Despite sustaining injuries from the crash, he fled the scene and did not report the accident to authorities.

Cisneros faced charges of intoxication manslaughter and accident involving death. Initially, he rejected a plea deal from the State of Texas that would have allowed him to serve concurrent ten-year sentences. Instead, he chose to plead guilty to both charges and have a jury decide his punishment, hoping for community supervision. However, the jury ultimately imposed the maximum sentence of ten years for each offense.

Following his conviction, Cisneros attempted to appeal, raising questions about whether he had knowingly waived his right to appeal and whether he received effective assistance from his legal counsel. The trial court had indicated that Cisneros waived his right to appeal, but there was no written record of this waiver, leading to confusion about his appellate rights.

The court noted that while trial counsel, Colleen Dunbar, claimed Cisneros verbally waived his rights in court, there was no formal record of this waiver. Additionally, Cisneros testified that he did not recall waiving his rights or discussing the implications of such a waiver with his attorney. The court found that the trial court had not adequately admonished Cisneros about his appellate rights at the time of the alleged waiver.

In its ruling, the Texas Court of Appeals, led by Justice Maricela Breedlove, concluded that Cisneros did not knowingly, intelligently, and voluntarily waive his right to appeal. The court stated, "The record does not support a conclusion of ineffective assistance of counsel." The court emphasized that a defendant's waiver of the right to appeal must be clear and well-understood, especially in cases where the defendant is pleading guilty without a negotiated agreement.

The ruling has important implications for Cisneros and others in similar situations. It reinforces the principle that defendants must be fully aware of their rights and the consequences of waiving them. The court's decision also highlights the responsibilities of defense attorneys to provide accurate legal advice regarding the potential for appeal following a guilty plea.

Going forward, this ruling may influence how courts handle cases involving waivers of appellate rights. It underscores the necessity for clear communication between defendants and their counsel about the implications of guilty pleas and the preservation of appellate rights.

As for what’s next for Cisneros, while he has the option to appeal the court's decision to a higher court, the ruling effectively affirms his convictions and sentences. There are no indications of pending related cases at this time.