A Texas court has granted Scott Anthony Hetrick a new trial after determining that his legal representation during his original trial was ineffective. Hetrick was convicted of multiple counts of sexual assault against a child and sentenced to a total of seventy years in prison. The ruling affects not only Hetrick but also raises questions about the legal standards for effective counsel in criminal cases.

The Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas issued this decision on November 19, 2026, in response to Hetrick's applications for writs of habeas corpus, identified as WR-96,732-01 and WR-96,732-02. The court found that Hetrick's trial attorneys failed to call a key witness, his wife Elizabeth Hetrick, to testify, despite promising the jury they would do so.

Background

Scott Hetrick was convicted in March 2023 of three counts of sexual assault of a child and one count of continuous sexual abuse of a child. His trial was marked by testimony from the complainant, B.C., who alleged that Hetrick had sexually assaulted her multiple times since she was a child. The prosecution presented evidence from police officers and medical professionals, including a sexual assault nurse examiner, who testified about B.C.'s claims and the lack of physical injuries.

During the trial, Hetrick's attorney stated in opening arguments that they would call Elizabeth Hetrick to testify, claiming she would provide crucial information about the case. However, the defense ultimately did not call her to the stand, which led to Hetrick's conviction. After his conviction, Hetrick filed for a writ of habeas corpus, arguing that his attorneys were ineffective for failing to present key evidence that could have supported his defense.

The Ruling

The court ruled that Hetrick's trial attorneys were constitutionally ineffective for not calling Elizabeth Hetrick as a witness. The opinion stated, "the failure of Applicant’s trial attorneys to call Hetrick to testify after the jury was repeatedly promised that they would hear from Hetrick permitted the jury to draw negative adverse inferences against Applicant." This failure to deliver on the promised testimony was deemed prejudicial to Hetrick's case.

The ruling was delivered by Judge Finley, with Judges Richardson, Newell, Walker, and Parker joining in the opinion. The dissenting opinion came from Presiding Judge Schenck and Judges Yeary, Keel, and McClure, who would deny the application for a writ of habeas corpus.

Impact

This decision has significant implications for Hetrick, as he will receive a new trial, allowing him another opportunity to present his defense. It also highlights the importance of effective legal representation in criminal cases. The court's ruling emphasizes that failing to follow through on promises made to a jury can lead to a miscarriage of justice. This case could set a precedent regarding the standards of effective counsel, particularly in cases involving serious allegations like sexual assault.

The ruling also raises broader questions about the criminal justice system's handling of cases involving child abuse allegations. The court's decision underscores the necessity for defense attorneys to thoroughly evaluate witness testimonies and to communicate effectively with their clients about trial strategies.

What's Next

Hetrick's case will now return to the lower court for a new trial. It remains to be seen whether the prosecution will pursue the same charges again or if any new evidence will emerge. The possibility of appeal exists, but the court's ruling on ineffective counsel has already granted Hetrick a significant victory.