The Michigan Court of Appeals recently issued a ruling in the case of Cynthia Zalewski v. US Bank Trust National Association, No. 378897, which addresses significant issues related to foreclosure procedures. The court's decision centers on whether a misstatement in the sheriff's deed regarding the redemption period constitutes an irregularity that could affect the validity of the foreclosure. This ruling has implications for homeowners facing foreclosure and the procedures that lenders must follow.

Cynthia Zalewski, the plaintiff in this case, inherited a property from her mother, Dorothy Zalewski, who had taken out a mortgage in 2007. After her mother's passing in 2013, Cynthia began making payments on the mortgage, which had been assigned to NewRez LLC. However, in 2021, due to financial difficulties caused by the COVID-19 pandemic, she was offered a moratorium on her payments. When she later discovered that her property was set for sheriff's sale, she learned that the mortgage had been transferred to US Bank National Association, which was responsible for the foreclosure.

The property was sold at a sheriff's sale on December 12, 2023, for approximately $180,000. However, the sheriff's deed incorrectly stated that the redemption period was six months, while the actual redemption period should have been 12 months due to the amount owed being less than two-thirds of the original mortgage. Cynthia attempted to redeem the property, but the incorrect redemption period complicated her efforts.

After filing a lawsuit on October 31, 2024, Cynthia raised multiple counts against several defendants, including US Bank and HP Foreclosure Solution. She argued that the sheriff's deed was defective and sought to quiet title, among other claims. The trial court initially ruled in favor of the defendants, stating that Cynthia lacked standing to challenge the foreclosure because she failed to redeem the property within the incorrect six-month period.

However, the Michigan Court of Appeals disagreed with the trial court's conclusion. The court found that the misstatement regarding the redemption period constituted an irregularity in the foreclosure process. The judge stated, "The incorrect redemption deadline on the sheriff’s deed constituted an irregularity in the foreclosure procedure." The court emphasized that this misstatement was not merely a clerical error but a significant issue that could affect a homeowner's ability to reclaim their property.

The court's ruling reversed the trial court's decision to grant summary disposition in favor of US Bank and HP Foreclosure Solution, stating that the trial court had erred in treating the incorrect redemption deadline as insignificant. The appellate court remanded the case for further consideration of whether Cynthia suffered prejudice due to the irregularity in the foreclosure procedure.

This ruling is significant for homeowners facing foreclosure, as it underscores the importance of strict adherence to foreclosure procedures and the potential consequences of any irregularities. The court's decision may set a precedent for similar cases, highlighting that homeowners may have grounds to challenge a foreclosure if they can demonstrate that an irregularity adversely affected their rights.

Looking ahead, it remains to be seen how this case will proceed following the remand. The trial court will need to evaluate whether Cynthia Zalewski experienced prejudice as a result of the incorrect redemption period stated in the sheriff's deed. This case may also prompt further scrutiny of foreclosure practices and the responsibilities of lenders in ensuring compliance with statutory requirements.

As of now, the court did not specify whether this decision could be appealed further. However, the case highlights critical issues surrounding foreclosure processes and the rights of homeowners in Michigan.