The Michigan Court of Appeals has issued a ruling in the case of Christine Oldenburg-McGee v. University of Michigan Regents, which addresses allegations of gender discrimination in pay. The court's decision impacts female physician assistants (PAs) at the University of Michigan's Michigan Medicine, who have claimed they are paid less than their male counterparts. This ruling is significant as it touches on issues of pay equity and the legal requirements for filing discrimination claims.

Christine Oldenburg-McGee, a physician assistant at Michigan Medicine, filed a class action lawsuit against the University of Michigan and several of its officials, alleging that female PAs were paid, on average, $9,000 less annually than similarly-situated male PAs. The lawsuit was filed under the Elliott-Larsen Civil Rights Act (ELCRA), which prohibits discrimination based on gender, among other factors. The case highlights ongoing concerns about wage disparities based on gender in the workplace.

Oldenburg-McGee's lawsuit arose after she advocated for closing the gender pay gap within her bargaining unit, the United Physician Assistants of Michigan Medicine (UPAMM). Despite negotiations that took place in 2021 to address salary issues, she argued that the agreements did not sufficiently resolve the wage gap and may have even entrenched it further. In April 2025, she filed a notice of intention to pursue her claims, stating that injuries had occurred within the past six months, which led to her formal class action filing shortly thereafter.

The university defendants, which include the Regents of the University of Michigan and several individuals, sought to dismiss the case, arguing that Oldenburg-McGee's claims were barred because she did not comply with the six-month notice requirement outlined in the Court of Claims Act (COCA). They contended that the notice was filed too late, as the gender-based wage gap had been an ongoing issue since at least 2021.

In its ruling, the court agreed with the defendants in part, stating that while Oldenburg-McGee could pursue claims for wage-gap payments made on or after October 3, 2024, any claims related to payments made before that date were barred due to the failure to meet the six-month notice requirement. The court noted, "Each time plaintiff and the putative class members were paid less than similarly-situated males, it gave rise to a potential ELCRA claim." This means that the court recognized the ongoing nature of the claims but also upheld the importance of adhering to statutory notice requirements.

Judge Sima G. Patel, along with Judges Christopher M. Murray and Kathleen A. Feeney, presided over the case. They emphasized that while the continuing violations doctrine does not apply to ELCRA claims, each wage payment constitutes a separate violation that can be pursued if timely filed. The court's decision effectively allows Oldenburg-McGee and others in her position to seek redress for more recent instances of pay discrimination while limiting the scope of claims based on earlier payments.

The implications of this ruling are significant for both the University of Michigan and its employees. It reinforces the necessity for institutions to address gender pay disparities proactively and ensures that employees are aware of the legal requirements for filing discrimination claims. The decision also serves as a reminder that while past violations may not be recoverable, ongoing discrimination can still be challenged in court.

Looking ahead, the university defendants may choose to appeal the ruling, particularly regarding the aspects of the case that were affirmed in favor of Oldenburg-McGee. Additionally, this case may set a precedent for how gender discrimination claims are handled in the future, particularly in relation to the notice requirements outlined in the COCA.

As of now, the court has remanded the case for further proceedings consistent with its opinion, meaning that the legal battle over gender pay equity at Michigan Medicine is far from over. The outcome of this case could have lasting effects on workplace policies and practices regarding pay equity and discrimination.