The Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York has ruled in favor of the County of Monroe Industrial Development Agency (COMIDA) in a case involving the condemnation of certain rights held by Target Corporation. The court's decision, issued on November 20, 2026, confirms the agency's actions and dismisses Target's petition challenging the condemnation. This ruling affects Target's operations in Irondequoit, New York, where it operates a retail store.

The case, titled Matter of Target Corp. v. County of Monroe Indus. Dev. Agency, was initiated after COMIDA scheduled a public hearing to discuss the proposed condemnation of Target's contractual rights related to properties near the former Medley Centre shopping center. The decision is significant as it clarifies the requirements for public notice in condemnation proceedings and the rights of property owners to challenge such actions.

Background

Target Corporation, a major retail chain, found itself in a dispute with the County of Monroe Industrial Development Agency regarding the condemnation of certain rights it held. The controversy arose when COMIDA announced plans to condemn specific contractual rights associated with Target's retail operations in Irondequoit, a suburb of Rochester. This action was part of a broader initiative to redevelop the area surrounding the now-defunct Medley Centre.

COMIDA conducted a public hearing to discuss the proposed condemnation, notifying Target through certified mail and Federal Express. The notice included information about the hearing's purpose, the date, and location. However, despite receiving notice, no representatives from Target attended the hearing. The only attendees voiced support for the condemnation, leading to COMIDA's approval of the action.

The Ruling

The court ruled unanimously to confirm COMIDA's determination and dismissed Target's petition. The judges included Whalen, Lindley, Ogden, Nowak, and Delconte. The court found that the notice of the public hearing met the requirements set forth by the New York Eminent Domain Procedure Law (EDPL). The court stated, "We conclude that COMIDA's notice and accompanying letter to petitioner satisfied those requirements."

Furthermore, the court noted that while the notice did not explicitly state the public use served by the proposed project, it was not required to do so. The ruling emphasized that the purpose of the public hearing was to outline the project and that the notice provided was adequate. The court explained, "Notice of the purpose of the public hearing, which is required by EDPL 202, is not the same as notice of the purpose of the proposed public project."

Impact

This ruling has significant implications for Target Corporation and potentially for other businesses facing similar condemnation actions. The court's decision reinforces the idea that property owners must actively participate in public hearings to preserve their right to challenge condemnations later. The ruling clarifies that failure to attend such hearings can limit the ability to contest the actions taken by agencies like COMIDA.

Moreover, the decision sets a precedent regarding the sufficiency of notices in condemnation proceedings. It indicates that the accompanying documentation, even if not part of the primary notice, can be considered in determining whether the requirements of the EDPL have been met. This could influence how future notices are crafted and how agencies communicate with property owners.

What's Next

Target Corporation may consider appealing the decision, although the court's ruling appears to be firmly grounded in the statutory requirements of the EDPL. Details regarding any potential appeal or related cases were not available in the court filing.