A New York appellate court has ruled that Utica First Insurance Company must defend Ratava, LLC in a personal injury lawsuit. This decision, made on November 20, 2026, affects how insurance companies handle claims related to negligence and personal injury. The ruling clarifies the insurer's obligations under a commercial policy, which is significant for businesses relying on insurance for legal protection.

The case, Ratava, LLC v. Utica First Ins. Co., was filed under docket number 829 CA 25-01990. The dispute arose when a patron of Ratava's establishment, Tow Bar Inn, alleged injuries due to the company's negligence. Ratava sought a declaratory judgment, asserting that Utica First was required to provide a defense in the underlying lawsuit.

Ratava, LLC operates the Tow Bar Inn and is the plaintiff in this case. Utica First Insurance Company is the defendant, which issued a commercial "Businessowners Policy" to Ratava. The underlying lawsuit was initiated by a patron who claimed to have sustained injuries on Ratava's premises. The patron’s complaint focused solely on negligence without mentioning any altercation. However, Utica First denied coverage, citing an "Assault Battery Exclusion" in the policy, claiming that the injuries were related to an altercation.

The case reached the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York after the Supreme Court in Herkimer County denied Ratava's motion for partial summary judgment. The lower court concluded that Utica First was entitled to further discovery before a determination could be made regarding its duty to defend Ratava.

The appellate court modified the lower court's order, granting Ratava's motion in part. The court ruled that Utica First is obligated to defend Ratava in the underlying action. The opinion stated, "It is well settled that an insurance company's duty to defend is 'exceedingly broad' and an insurer will be called upon to provide a defense whenever the allegations of the complaint 'suggest... a reasonable possibility of coverage.'" This emphasizes that an insurer must provide a defense if there is any possibility that the allegations could be covered by the insurance policy.

The court further explained that the allegations in the underlying complaint were solely about premises liability, which falls under the coverage of the policy. It noted, "We conclude that plaintiff met its initial burden on its motion, inasmuch as the causes of action in the underlying complaint sound solely in premises liability, specifically alleging plaintiff's negligent maintenance of its premises, which would be covered under the terms of the policy." This ruling reinforces the principle that insurance companies have a duty to defend their insureds in lawsuits where there is a potential for coverage.

Additionally, the court determined that Ratava is entitled to choose its own legal counsel for the defense, and Utica First must pay the reasonable attorney fees and related costs. The ruling stated, "inasmuch as [defendant's] interest in defending the lawsuit is in conflict with [plaintiff]'s interest[,]... [plaintiff] is entitled to defense by an attorney of [plaintiff's] own choosing, whose reasonable fee is to be paid by [defendant]." This aspect of the ruling is crucial for businesses that find themselves in disputes with their insurance providers.

The impact of this ruling extends beyond just Ratava, LLC. It sets a precedent for how insurance companies must respond to claims involving negligence and personal injury. Businesses can expect that if they face similar situations, insurers will have a broader obligation to defend them in lawsuits, provided there is any reasonable possibility of coverage based on the allegations.

Furthermore, this decision may influence how insurance policies are written and how exclusions are interpreted. Insurers may need to reconsider their strategies in denying coverage based on exclusions, particularly when the underlying claims do not clearly fall within those exclusions.

Looking ahead, the case could potentially be appealed to a higher court, although the opinion does not specify any immediate plans for an appeal. There may also be related cases pending that could further clarify insurance obligations in similar contexts. Details were not available in the court filing regarding any related cases.