The Nevada Supreme Court has upheld the conviction of Brandon Starr, who was found guilty of nearly 80 felony counts, including robbery and conspiracy. The court's decision, issued on November 21, 2026, affects Starr's legal standing after he sought postconviction relief, claiming ineffective assistance from his trial and appellate counsel.
The case stems from a series of fast-food restaurant robberies that occurred over a month. Starr and his co-defendant, Tony Hobson, were convicted following a jury trial. The court's ruling is significant as it reinforces the standards for proving ineffective assistance of counsel, which can be a complex legal hurdle for defendants seeking to overturn their convictions.
Brandon Starr, the appellant in this case, was convicted alongside co-defendant Tony Hobson for robbing 14 fast-food restaurants in Clark County, Nevada. The Eighth Judicial District Court, presided over by Judge Monica Trujillo, sentenced Starr after he was found guilty of multiple felony counts, including burglary and kidnapping. Following his conviction, Starr filed a postconviction petition for a writ of habeas corpus, seeking to challenge his conviction on the grounds of ineffective assistance of counsel.
The Nevada Court of Appeals had previously affirmed Starr's conviction in 2018. In his postconviction petition, Starr raised eight issues, primarily arguing that both his trial and appellate counsel failed to provide adequate representation, which ultimately affected the outcome of his case. The district court conducted an evidentiary hearing before denying his claims, leading to Starr's appeal to the Nevada Supreme Court.
In its ruling, the Nevada Supreme Court affirmed the district court's decision, stating that Starr did not demonstrate that his counsel's performance was deficient or that he suffered prejudice as a result. The court explained, "To prove ineffective assistance of counsel, a petitioner must demonstrate that counsel’s performance was deficient in that it fell below an objective standard of reasonableness, and resulting prejudice such that there is a reasonable probability that, but for counsel’s errors, the outcome of the proceedings would have been different." This standard is derived from the landmark case Strickland v. Washington.
The court specifically addressed several of Starr's claims, including the failure to call an alibi witness, the handling of jury instructions, and the decision not to sever his trial from Hobson's. For example, regarding the alibi witness, Shana Kindle, the court found that while counsel had made efforts to secure her testimony, concerns about her credibility and cooperation justified the decision not to pursue her further. The court noted, "Counsel investigated Kindle as an alibi witness and served Kindle with a subpoena to secure her presence... Because counsel adequately investigated Kindle and was presented with legitimate concerns about Kindle’s cooperation and credibility, counsel was not deficient for deciding not to further pursue efforts to secure Kindle’s attendance."
Additionally, the court ruled that Starr's trial and appellate counsel were not ineffective for failing to clarify jury instructions regarding potential punishments. The court stated that trial counsel successfully communicated to the jury that they could consider the benefits received by a witness in weighing credibility, thus showing that counsel's performance was reasonable.
The ruling also addressed Starr's claims regarding the failure to sever his trial from that of his co-defendant and the failure to present expert testimony. The court found that there was no basis for severance as the evidence against Starr remained strong regardless of the joint trial. The court concluded that the evidence presented at trial, including video and forensic evidence, supported the jury's decision to convict Starr.
The impact of this ruling is significant for Starr, as it confirms the strength of the evidence against him and the adequacy of his legal representation during trial. The court's decision serves as a reminder of the high bar defendants must meet to prove ineffective assistance of counsel. This ruling may also influence future cases where defendants seek to appeal based on claims of inadequate representation.
Moving forward, Starr's options for appeal are limited as the Nevada Supreme Court's ruling is final. There are no indications in the court filing of any pending related cases or further legal actions that Starr may pursue. The court's affirmation of the lower court's decision effectively closes this chapter of Starr's legal battle.
Read Next
Nevada court affirms custody ruling in Capparelli case
Nevada Supreme Court affirms dismissal of election challenge
Nevada court affirms ruling against vexatious litigant Van Damme
Court dismisses appeals of Timothy Ehn in fraud case
Texas Court of Appeals upholds assault conviction of Curry
Air Force Court Reviews Rulings in Sexual Assault Case










