The Texas Court of Appeals recently ruled on a significant case involving The Dow Chemical Company, Union Carbide Corporation, and Performance Materials NA, Inc. The court granted part of a petition for a writ of mandamus concerning the discovery of the companies' net worth. This ruling affects the ongoing litigation stemming from a tragic incident in 2019 that resulted in the death of two workers and injuries to others.
The court's decision matters because it addresses the limits of discovery in civil litigation, particularly regarding financial information that may not be relevant or necessary for the case at hand. The outcome could influence how similar cases are handled in the future, especially concerning the enforcement of discovery agreements.
Background
The case originated from a tragic incident in 2019 at a facility in Pasadena, Texas, where carbon monoxide exposure led to the deaths of two workers and injuries to two others. The families of the deceased and the injured workers filed a lawsuit against The Dow Chemical Company, Union Carbide Corporation, and Performance Materials NA, Inc., alleging negligence and gross negligence.
As the case progressed, the parties involved signed an amended scheduling order, which stipulated that all discovery must be completed by July 2025. This agreement was intended to provide a clear timeline for the exchange of information necessary for the trial. However, in October 2026, weeks into the trial, the plaintiffs filed a motion seeking the companies' net worth information, claiming it was relevant due to their allegations of gross negligence.
The Ruling
The Texas Court of Appeals, in a memorandum opinion filed on November 20, 2026, addressed the petition for a writ of mandamus filed by the companies. The court ruled that the trial court had abused its discretion by compelling the net worth discovery after the agreed-upon deadline had passed. The judges on the panel included Chief Justice Christopher and Justices Wilson and Bridges.
The court stated, "The trial court abused its discretion when it failed to enforce the agreement and ordered relators to produce net worth discovery fifteen months after the parties chose to end discovery."
The court noted that the agreement to conclude discovery by July 2025 was enforceable under Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 11, which requires that agreements between parties be in writing and filed with the court. The court found no evidence that the trial court had good cause to set aside this agreement, thus reinforcing the importance of adhering to discovery timelines.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for the parties involved and for future cases. By upholding the enforceability of the discovery agreement, the court emphasized the importance of adhering to established timelines in litigation. This decision may deter parties from seeking additional discovery after agreed-upon deadlines, reinforcing the principle that discovery should be conducted in a timely manner.
Moreover, the ruling clarifies that a trial court must have good cause to modify discovery agreements. This sets a precedent that could influence how courts handle similar requests for discovery in the future, particularly in cases involving corporate defendants who may be subject to extensive financial scrutiny during litigation.
What's Next
The court's ruling allows the trial to continue without the compelled net worth discovery, as the petition was granted in part. The request to vacate the order denying Dow Chemical's motion to quash trial subpoenas was dismissed as moot. It remains to be seen whether the plaintiffs will appeal this decision or if there are related cases pending that could further influence the legal landscape surrounding discovery practices in Texas.
Read Next
Texas Court of Appeals upholds assault conviction of Curry
Texas Court of Appeals Remands Case After Settlement Agreement
Texas Court affirms temporary order in divorce appeal case
Fifth Circuit Court Denies Mandamus in G6 Hospitality Case
California court allows substitution in labor law case
Nevada Supreme Court denies writ petition in tort case










