The California Court of Appeal has ruled that Nafisa Tarin can substitute for her deceased father, Kasim Tarin, in a labor law case against RADC Enterprises, Inc. This decision impacts the enforcement of labor rights under the Private Attorneys General Act (PAGA) and clarifies the rules regarding who can bring such claims. The ruling is significant for employees who may want to pursue claims on behalf of others, especially in cases where the original plaintiff has passed away.

Kasim Tarin originally filed a complaint against RADC Enterprises, alleging violations of various labor laws, including wage and hour regulations. After his death in January 2025, the trial court allowed his daughter, Nafisa Tarin, to continue some claims but denied her request to substitute in for the PAGA claim, stating she lacked standing since she was never an employee of RADC. Nafisa sought a writ of mandate from the Court of Appeal to challenge this decision.

Background

The Private Attorneys General Act, enacted in 2004, allows employees to sue on behalf of the state for labor code violations. The law enables aggrieved employees to seek civil penalties against employers, acting as private attorneys general. To have standing under PAGA, an individual must be an employee of the employer and have suffered at least one violation of the Labor Code.

Kasim Tarin filed his PAGA claim on March 24, 2023, alleging that RADC violated several labor laws regarding meal breaks, overtime pay, and wage statements. He passed away in January 2025, and shortly thereafter, Nafisa was granted permission to continue some claims but was denied the right to pursue the PAGA claim. The trial court ruled that she could not substitute for her father because she had never worked for RADC.

The Ruling

The California Court of Appeal ruled in favor of Nafisa Tarin, stating that the trial court erred in denying her request to substitute in for her father’s PAGA claim. The court emphasized that allowing substitution is consistent with the goals of the PAGA, which aims to strengthen labor law enforcement. The ruling stated, "The trial court abused its discretion in denying Tarin leave to amend the complaint to substitute Praster as named plaintiff in the representative Private Attorneys General Act action."

The court also noted that the proposed substitute, Monica Praster, was an aggrieved employee who had worked for RADC and had suffered similar violations. The ruling clarified that Praster's standing as an aggrieved employee was sufficient for her to substitute in for the PAGA claim, regardless of the timing of her administrative notice.

Impact

This ruling has significant implications for labor law enforcement in California. It establishes that a successor in interest can substitute for a deceased plaintiff in a PAGA claim, provided that the substitute meets the standing requirements. This decision allows for continuity in legal actions that seek to hold employers accountable for labor law violations, even after the original plaintiff has passed away.

The ruling may encourage more employees to pursue claims under the PAGA, knowing that their rights can be protected even if they cannot continue the case themselves. It also reinforces the idea that the PAGA is designed to benefit the public and ensure that labor laws are enforced effectively.

What's Next

Following this ruling, the trial court must grant Nafisa Tarin leave to amend the complaint to substitute Monica Praster as the named plaintiff. There is no indication in the court filing about whether RADC Enterprises plans to appeal this decision. However, the ruling sets a precedent for similar cases in the future, potentially influencing how PAGA claims are handled when the original plaintiff is no longer able to continue.