The California Court of Appeal has affirmed a lower court's decision to dismiss a lawsuit filed by Russell M. Frandsen against National ACO, LLC (NACO). This ruling, issued on November 20, 2026, impacts Frandsen and NACO, particularly concerning the involuntary dissolution of the company. The court concluded that Frandsen's claims were moot due to the dismissal of a related federal action.
The case, docket number B352811, stems from a dispute between Frandsen and NACO regarding a claim against the federal government. The court's decision emphasizes the importance of procedural issues in legal disputes and highlights the challenges faced by individuals seeking to dissolve a company under California law.
Background
Russell M. Frandsen is a member of NACO, which is a limited liability company formed under California law. NACO is managed by Andre Berger, who owns approximately 52.5 percent of the company, while Frandsen holds about 42.8 percent. The company had a contract with the United States Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) and faced a significant loss of over $2.9 million, which CMS collected against a bond posted by NACO.
In August 2020, NACO retained Frandsen on a contingency basis to pursue a claim against CMS. However, in May 2025, Berger discharged Frandsen and instructed him to dismiss the federal action that Frandsen had filed on NACO's behalf. Frandsen argued that dismissing the action would result in losing the opportunity to recover the claimed losses, as the statute of limitations had run out on contractual claims. Subsequently, Frandsen filed a lawsuit for NACO's involuntary dissolution, claiming that the company had no assets other than the claim against CMS.
The dispute escalated when Frandsen sought a court appointment of a receiver to manage NACO's affairs and pursue the claim against CMS. However, NACO dismissed its federal action, which led to the trial court granting a motion for judgment on the pleadings, concluding that Frandsen's claims were moot.
The Ruling
The California Court of Appeal ruled in favor of NACO, affirming the trial court's decision to dismiss Frandsen's lawsuit. The court stated, "We reject Frandsen’s argument that the judgment is void or invalid as a result of NACO’s suspension." The court explained that the dismissal of NACO's federal action rendered Frandsen's claims moot, meaning there was no longer a legal basis for the lawsuit.
The court also addressed Frandsen's argument regarding NACO's corporate suspension, concluding that it did not affect the trial court's jurisdiction to grant the motion for judgment on the pleadings. The ruling emphasized that the revival of corporate powers retroactively validated actions taken during the suspension, thereby upholding the trial court's judgment.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for Frandsen and NACO. It underscores the importance of addressing procedural issues and the potential consequences of corporate actions, such as suspensions, on legal proceedings. The court's decision confirms that a corporation's inability to defend itself due to suspension does not invalidate the trial court's jurisdiction to rule on motions.
The outcome may also deter similar lawsuits in the future, as it highlights the necessity for plaintiffs to ensure that their claims are viable and not rendered moot by related actions. This case serves as a reminder of the complexities involved in corporate governance and the legal ramifications of disputes among members.
What's Next
Frandsen may consider appealing the decision, but the court's ruling provides a strong precedent for NACO. There is no indication of any related case pending that could affect this ruling. The court's decision stands as a significant legal outcome for both parties involved.
Read Next
California court upholds child support judgment against trust
Court reverses dismissal in Astrachan v. Los Angeles Community College
California Court of Appeal reverses Fred Brown's sentence
Nevada court affirms custody ruling in Capparelli case
Ohio Court reverses dismissal of complaint against officials
Court affirms dismissal of claims against Specialized Loan










