A Texas court has reversed part of a lower court's ruling in a workplace harassment case involving Marlana Beasley and Tia Glasco against R2R and D, LLC, doing business as Superod. The court found that there were genuine issues of material fact regarding the hostile work environment claim, which means the case will return to the lower court for further proceedings. This decision could have significant implications for workplace harassment claims in Texas.
The case, filed under docket number 11-25-00047-CV, stems from allegations made by Beasley and Glasco that they faced a hostile work environment and retaliation after reporting the behavior of their supervisor, Dwain Fox. The court's decision to reverse part of the summary judgment means that the hostile work environment claim will be reconsidered, while the retaliation claim was upheld.
Background
Marlana Beasley and Tia Glasco worked as executive assistants at Superod, where they reported to Fox, the company's vice president. The dispute arose after Beasley and Glasco claimed they were subjected to sexual harassment and a hostile work environment due to Fox's behavior. They alleged that Fox made inappropriate comments and engaged in unwanted physical contact, including groping during a Christmas party.
After the two women were terminated—Beasley outright and Glasco offered reassignment, which she declined—they filed a lawsuit against Superod. The trial court granted Superod's motion for summary judgment, ruling that the evidence did not support their claims of a hostile work environment or retaliation. This led to the appeal by Beasley and Glasco.
The Ruling
The Texas Court of Appeals ruled that there were genuine issues of material fact regarding the hostile work environment claim. The court stated, "we conclude that genuine issues of material fact remain as to the challenged element of Appellants’ hostile work environment claim." This indicates that the court believes there is enough evidence for the case to be reconsidered in the lower court.
However, the court upheld the trial court's decision regarding the retaliation claim, stating that Beasley did not engage in a protected activity that would warrant protection under the law. The court noted that Beasley’s vague reports of bullying and harassment did not sufficiently alert Superod to the unlawful discrimination she was experiencing.
Impact
This ruling is significant for workplace harassment claims in Texas, as it reinforces the importance of addressing hostile work environments. The court's decision to reverse the summary judgment on the hostile work environment claim means that Beasley and Glasco will have another opportunity to present their case. This could encourage other employees facing similar situations to come forward, knowing that their claims may be taken more seriously.
The ruling also highlights the need for employers to ensure that their anti-harassment policies are effectively communicated and enforced. The court found that Superod did not provide sufficient evidence that they had properly disseminated their anti-harassment policy or trained employees on it, which could expose them to liability in similar cases.
What's Next
The case will return to the trial court for further proceedings regarding the hostile work environment claim. The court's ruling does not prevent Superod from appealing the decision, but details on any potential appeal were not available in the court filing. The outcome of this case could set a precedent for how workplace harassment claims are handled in Texas moving forward.
Read Next
Texas Court of Appeals upholds assault conviction of Curry
Texas Court of Appeals Remands Case After Settlement Agreement
Texas Court affirms temporary order in divorce appeal case
Ninth Circuit revives Eagleman's disability discrimination case
Court revives appeal over concealed-carry license revocation
Court affirms Navy's actions against engineer Khaghani










