A Texas appeals court has upheld a ruling that awarded zero damages to Fariborz Hadjebian in his negligence lawsuit against Sandra Dunning. The decision came after a jury found that Dunning's actions had caused a car accident but did not believe Hadjebian had proven any damages resulting from the incident. This ruling is significant as it highlights the challenges plaintiffs face in proving damages in personal injury cases.
The case, Fariborz Hadjebian v. Sandra Dunning, was filed in the Texas Court of Appeals, 5th District (Dallas) under docket number 05-25-01054-CV. The court issued its opinion on November 9, 2026, affirming the lower court's judgment. Hadjebian claimed that Dunning's negligence led to an accident on August 2, 2021, but the jury ultimately awarded him no compensation.
Hadjebian and his wife, Elnaz Entayatfar, filed their original petition after a car accident where Dunning was involved. According to the petition, Hadjebian alleged that Dunning was driving negligently through an intersection, causing another vehicle to collide with his car. The case went to trial, where the jury heard evidence about the accident and its aftermath.
During the trial, it was established that Hadjebian was stopped at a red light when Dunning attempted to turn left and was struck by another vehicle driven by Ryan Noyes. The collision caused Dunning's car to spin and ultimately struck Hadjebian's vehicle. Despite the jury finding Dunning at fault, they awarded Hadjebian no damages for his claims of injury.
After the trial, Hadjebian filed a motion for a new trial, arguing that the jury's decision was not supported by sufficient evidence and that the trial court had abused its discretion by limiting the trial to only one day. He contended that this time constraint prevented him from presenting all of his evidence, particularly testimony from his medical providers.
The court ruled on these issues, stating that the trial court had the discretion to control the trial's length and that Hadjebian failed to preserve his complaint about the time limit for appeal. The judges on the panel included Justice Nancy Kennedy, who authored the opinion, along with Justices Clinton and Rossini.
In addressing Hadjebian's claim regarding the jury's zero damages award, the court noted that the jury has significant discretion in determining damages. The opinion stated, "The mere fact of injury does not prove compensable pain and mental anguish." The court emphasized that the jury may disbelieve a witness, even if their testimony is uncontradicted.
Hadjebian had provided extensive medical records and personal testimony to support his claim of injuries resulting from the accident. However, the jury found inconsistencies between his testimony and the medical records, which documented his ongoing pain issues prior to the accident. The jury concluded that while Dunning's negligence caused the accident, Hadjebian did not sufficiently prove that his injuries were a direct result of that incident.
The court affirmed that the jury's decision was not clearly wrong or unjust, stating that their determination of damages was within their purview. This ruling underscores the importance of clear and convincing evidence in personal injury cases, particularly when prior injuries are involved.
The outcome of this case may have implications for future personal injury claims, especially those involving multiple incidents of injury or preexisting conditions. Plaintiffs may need to be more diligent in establishing a clear connection between their injuries and the defendant's actions to secure damages.
As for what’s next, Hadjebian has the option to appeal this decision to the Texas Supreme Court, although it is unclear whether he will pursue that route. There are no related cases pending at this time.
Read Next
Court affirms summary judgment in assault case against Talib
Texas court affirms sanctions against Mid-American Supply's CEO
Texas court dismisses appeal in child indecency case
Court reverses summary judgment in medical malpractice case
Court denies plaintiff's request to join two injury cases
Court upholds ruling in personal injury case against landlord










