The New York Court of Appeals has ruled in favor of a patient in a podiatric malpractice case against Ernest L. Isaacson, DPM, P.C. The decision, made on November 19, 2026, allows the case to move forward, impacting how healthcare professionals are held accountable during emergencies. This ruling is significant for patients seeking justice in malpractice claims, particularly during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Robert Zain, the patient in this case, brought a lawsuit against the podiatrist and his practice, claiming malpractice related to treatments he received during the pandemic. The court's decision affirms that the defendants, including Isaacson's practice, cannot claim immunity under the Emergency or Disaster Treatment Protection Act (EDTPA) for their actions.
The EDTPA was enacted to protect healthcare providers from liability during emergencies, but the court found that podiatrists do not qualify for this immunity. This ruling affects not only Zain but also sets a precedent for other patients who may have experienced malpractice during the pandemic.
Background
The case, Zain v. Ernest L. Isaacson, DPM, P.C., was filed after Zain alleged that he suffered harm due to the treatment he received from the defendants during the COVID-19 pandemic. The dispute centers around whether the defendants can be held liable for malpractice or if they are protected under the EDTPA.
The EDTPA was designed to provide legal protection to healthcare professionals during the COVID-19 emergency, allowing them to operate under relaxed regulations. However, the law specifies which types of healthcare professionals are covered under its provisions. The defendants argued that they were entitled to immunity under this act, claiming they were providing necessary healthcare services during the pandemic.
The case reached the New York Court of Appeals after the Appellate Division denied the defendants' motion to dismiss the complaint. The defendants contended that the lower courts erred in their judgment, leading to the appeal.
The Ruling
The New York Court of Appeals ruled unanimously to affirm the lower court's decision, allowing Zain's malpractice claim to proceed. The court stated, "The lower courts properly denied defendants' CPLR 3211 (a) (7) motion to dismiss plaintiff's complaint for failure to state a cause of action alleging podiatric malpractice." This ruling indicates that the court found sufficient grounds for Zain's case to move forward.
Furthermore, the court noted that the defendants failed to establish their entitlement to immunity under the EDTPA. The opinion highlighted that podiatrists are not listed among the healthcare professionals covered by the act. The court emphasized, "Defendants failed to show that they qualify as health care professionals pursuant to former section 3081 (4) (e) because they were 'providing health care services within the scope of authority permitted by a COVID-19 emergency rule.'" This statement clarifies that the court did not find the defendants' arguments convincing regarding their immunity claims.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for healthcare providers and patients alike. By affirming that podiatrists do not qualify for immunity under the EDTPA, the court sets a precedent for how similar cases may be handled in the future. This decision could encourage more patients to come forward with malpractice claims against healthcare providers, especially those who received treatment during the pandemic.
The ruling also highlights the importance of clearly defining which healthcare professionals are covered under emergency laws. As the healthcare landscape continues to evolve, particularly in response to public health emergencies, this case may influence future legislation and legal interpretations regarding healthcare liability.
What's Next
The defendants may seek to appeal this ruling to a higher court, but details were not available in the court filing regarding any plans for further legal action. As of now, Zain's case will proceed in the lower courts, allowing for a full examination of the malpractice claims.
Read Next
Court orders New York to disclose certain public records
Court upholds JPMorgan Chase's trust accounting in Rockefeller case
New York attorney publicly censured for conduct at protest
New York Court upholds dismissal of vicarious liability case
Court orders review of employment records in injury case
Court rules on workers' compensation case involving claim denial









