A California Court of Appeal has reversed a lower court's decision in a malicious prosecution case involving Patrick Chraghchian and the Law Offices of Bruce E. Altschuld. The ruling, issued on November 17, 2026, affects how malicious prosecution claims are evaluated in the context of anti-SLAPP motions, which are designed to protect free speech and petition rights.

The case centers on a dispute between Chraghchian, a real estate developer, and Barrios, an investor who had previously sued Chraghchian and his business partners over a failed real estate project. The outcome of this case is significant as it clarifies the standards for proving malice in malicious prosecution claims and the application of anti-SLAPP protections.

Background

Patrick Chraghchian and Joel Leebove formed 123 Los Robles LLC in 2005 to develop a condominium complex in Pasadena. Albert Barrios and other investors joined the LLC. Tensions arose when the managers of the LLC entered into agreements that some investors claimed violated the LLC's operating agreement. Barrios and others filed a derivative lawsuit against the managers in December 2015, alleging various breaches of fiduciary duty.

The lawsuit was ultimately unsuccessful, with a judicial referee recommending dismissal due to a lack of merit. Despite this, Barrios continued to pursue the case, which eventually led to a trial court ruling in favor of the managers. Barrios appealed, but the appellate court upheld the trial court's decision.

In November 2024, Chraghchian filed a complaint against Barrios and the Law Offices of Bruce E. Altschuld for malicious prosecution, claiming that the underlying lawsuit was baseless and intended to harm his reputation. The Law Offices of Bruce E. Altschuld filed an anti-SLAPP motion to strike Chraghchian's complaint, arguing that it arose from protected activity.

The Ruling

The California Court of Appeal ruled that the trial court erred in denying the anti-SLAPP motion. The court held that Chraghchian failed to establish a probability of prevailing on his malicious prosecution claim. The opinion stated, "the mere fact that Barrios’s claims in the underlying lawsuit ultimately proved unmeritorious does not necessarily mean they were prosecuted without probable cause."

The court emphasized that to establish malice, there must be evidence that the defendants continued to prosecute the action after becoming aware that it lacked probable cause. The court found that Chraghchian did not provide sufficient evidence to support the claim of malice, stating that his evidence amounted to mere speculation.

Impact

This ruling has important implications for future malicious prosecution claims in California. It clarifies that a lack of probable cause alone is insufficient to establish malice. Plaintiffs must provide concrete evidence showing that the defendants acted with an improper purpose when pursuing the underlying action. This decision reinforces the protective measures of the anti-SLAPP statute, which aims to prevent frivolous lawsuits that could hinder free speech and petition rights.

The ruling also highlights the importance of the judicial process in assessing the merits of claims before they proceed to trial. By reversing the trial court's decision, the appellate court has set a precedent that could deter similar claims in the future, requiring plaintiffs to meet a higher standard of proof in malicious prosecution cases.

What's Next

The appellate court directed the trial court to grant the anti-SLAPP motion, dismiss the complaint with prejudice, and award attorney fees and costs to Barrios and the Law Offices of Bruce E. Altschuld. This ruling can potentially be appealed to the California Supreme Court, but it remains to be seen if the parties will seek further review.