The California Court of Appeal ruled on November 17, 2026, in the case of Litynski v. Deja Vu Services (D086028), reversing a lower court's decision that denied a motion to compel arbitration. The ruling affects Rita Jean Litynski and several companies associated with Deja Vu Services, as it requires Litynski's employment claims to be resolved through arbitration instead of in court. This decision highlights the enforceability of arbitration agreements in employment contracts.

The case began when Litynski filed a class action complaint against multiple defendants, including Deja Vu Services, in March 2024. She alleged that during her employment from July to September 2023, the defendants violated various labor laws, including failing to pay minimum and overtime wages, as well as not providing required meal and rest breaks. The dispute escalated to the courts when the defendants sought to enforce an arbitration agreement that Litynski had signed as part of her employment onboarding.

The arbitration agreement included a delegation clause, which stated that any disputes regarding the validity or enforceability of the agreement should be decided by an arbitrator. The defendants argued that this clause meant that any challenges to the arbitration agreement should be handled by the arbitrator, not the court. However, Litynski contended that the agreement was unconscionable and therefore unenforceable. She claimed that it was presented as a non-negotiable contract of adhesion and included several unfair provisions.

Initially, the trial court sided with Litynski, ruling that the arbitration agreement was unconscionable and declining to sever its problematic provisions. The court's decision was based on its finding that the agreement had a low degree of procedural unconscionability and contained multiple substantively unconscionable provisions. These included an overly broad definition of covered claims, a confidentiality clause, and a requirement for Litynski to bear certain costs associated with arbitration.

However, the Court of Appeal found that the trial court had erred in its decision. The court emphasized that the delegation clause in the arbitration agreement clearly and unmistakably assigned the responsibility of determining the validity and enforceability of the agreement to the arbitrator. The court quoted, "the arbitrator shall have exclusive authority to resolve any and all disputes over the formation, validity, interpretation, scope, and/or enforceability of any part of this agreement."

The appellate court noted that under the United States Supreme Court's ruling in Rent-A-Center, West, Inc. v. Jackson, parties can delegate the authority to decide enforceability issues to an arbitrator. The court concluded that Litynski's claims of unconscionability were not specific to the delegation clause itself, which meant that the arbitrator should decide the unconscionability of the entire agreement.

The ruling has significant implications for employment disputes involving arbitration agreements. By reversing the lower court's decision, the Court of Appeal reinforced the validity of arbitration agreements and the importance of delegation clauses. This ruling could encourage employers to include such clauses in their contracts, as it provides a clear pathway for resolving disputes outside of court.

Looking ahead, the case may still have further developments, as Litynski could potentially appeal the ruling or challenge the arbitration agreement again in arbitration. The appellate court's decision does not preclude future legal actions regarding the merits of Litynski's claims or the arbitration process itself. However, for now, the court has mandated that the arbitration agreement be enforced, requiring Litynski's claims to be resolved through arbitration.