The Michigan Court of Appeals recently affirmed the rulings of a lower court in the divorce case of Christine Aimie Harmon and William Robert Harmon. The court's decision, issued on November 17, 2026, affects how marital assets are divided and the awarding of attorney fees in divorce cases. This ruling is significant for individuals navigating similar disputes in Michigan.
The case revolves around the couple's divorce, which began when Christine filed for divorce in November 2022 after more than 16 years of marriage. The court's rulings addressed the division of marital property, spousal support, and attorney fees, all of which were contested by William. The court's decisions have implications for how assets are valued and divided in future divorce proceedings.
Christine and William Harmon began dating in 1996 and married in June 2006. Their marriage included two daughters. Following Christine's filing for divorce, the couple engaged in a contentious legal battle over their assets, which included a home, vehicles, and a sailboat. The trial court conducted a lengthy bench trial to resolve these disputes. The court eventually ruled on the equitable distribution of their assets, granting Christine the majority share of certain assets and awarding her attorney fees.
The trial court's judgment included dividing the marital estate and awarding Christine spousal support and attorney fees totaling $67,587.77. The court found that Christine lacked the ability to pay these fees while William, who earned significantly more, could afford to cover them. William appealed these decisions, arguing that the court's rulings were incorrect.
In its ruling, the Michigan Court of Appeals upheld the lower court's decisions regarding the division of assets and the awarding of attorney fees. The judges emphasized the importance of equitable distribution in divorce cases, stating, "The goal in distributing marital assets in a divorce proceeding is to reach an equitable distribution of property in light of all the circumstances." The court found no clear error in the lower court's assessment of the couple's assets and the reasoning behind its decisions.
One of the key issues in the appeal was the division of the marital home. William argued that he should receive a larger share since the home was in his name and he had made all mortgage payments prior to their marriage. However, the trial court ruled that Christine had significantly contributed to the home, both financially and through her labor, which justified an equal division of the proceeds from its sale.
Additionally, the court addressed the couple's sailboat and vehicles. William contended that the sailboat should be considered his separate property as he purchased it before the marriage. The trial court found that Christine had also contributed to the boat's upkeep and improvements, thus classifying it as a marital asset. The court's rulings on the vehicles followed similar reasoning, affirming the trial court's valuations and classifications.
The court also upheld the trial court's decision to award Christine postjudgment attorney fees. The judges noted that these fees were justified due to William's noncompliance with court orders and his refusal to provide necessary financial information during the proceedings. The court stated that attorney fees can be awarded when one party is unable to pay while the other has the means to do so, which was evident in this case.
The ruling has broader implications for future divorce cases in Michigan. It reinforces the principle that contributions to marital property, whether financial or through labor, can affect asset division. The decision also highlights the court's willingness to impose attorney fees on a party who does not comply with court orders, ensuring that one spouse does not bear the financial burden of legal proceedings alone.
Looking ahead, it is unclear if William will appeal the ruling further. The court's decision in this case sets a precedent for how similar disputes may be resolved in the future, particularly in terms of asset division and attorney fee awards in divorce cases. As the legal landscape continues to evolve, this case will likely serve as a reference point for future rulings.
Read Next
Michigan Court of Appeals hears dissent on evidence destruction
Michigan Court of Appeals rules on parental rights case
Court affirms property tax valuation in Ann Arbor dispute
Vermont court upholds small claims judgment against Feinberg
Pennsylvania court affirms child support ruling in Burda case
Vermont court denies motion to amend wrongful death complaint










