The Indiana Court of Appeals has affirmed a lower court's decision granting summary judgment in favor of insurance agent Kyle Knutson in a negligence case brought by Mark and Rochelle Traino. The ruling, issued on November 17, 2026, stems from a dispute over auto insurance coverage that the Trainos claim was mishandled, ultimately leading to a denied claim following an accident.
This case matters because it highlights the responsibilities of insurance agents and the importance of understanding policy details. The outcome could impact how similar cases are handled in the future, especially concerning the statute of limitations in negligence claims against insurance agents.
Background
Mark Traino owned a business called Xtreme Clean, Inc., which provided various services, including snow removal and lawn care. In June 2019, he sought commercial auto insurance for his business through Knutson, who was acting as an agent for Auto-Owners Insurance Company. During this process, Traino completed an application that did not include his 2019 Volkswagen Atlas.
At the same time, Traino also applied for personal auto insurance with Safeco Insurance, which did include the Atlas. The Trainos received policies from both companies, but when Traino was involved in an accident in February 2021 while driving the Atlas, Auto-Owners denied the claim, stating the vehicle was not covered under the commercial policy.
In January 2023, the Trainos filed a multi-count complaint against Knutson and Auto-Owners, alleging negligence in failing to procure the insurance coverage they requested. The case eventually reached the Indiana Court of Appeals after the trial court granted Knutson's motion for summary judgment, which the Trainos contested.
The Ruling
The Indiana Court of Appeals ruled that the trial court did not err in granting summary judgment in favor of Knutson. Judge Pyle stated, "The statute of limitations began to run two years after the 2019 start of coverage and barred Count 3 of the Trainos complaint, which was filed in 2023." This decision indicates that the Trainos' claim was time-barred because they did not file within the required two years after the cause of action accrued.
The court emphasized that the Trainos should have been aware of the lack of coverage for the Atlas at the time the policy was issued. The ruling referenced a previous case, Filip v. Block, to illustrate that the limitations period begins when the policyholder knows or should have known about the inadequacy of coverage.
Impact
This ruling reinforces the importance of understanding insurance policies and the responsibilities of both agents and clients. It establishes that clients must be diligent in reviewing their policies and understanding what is covered. The court's reliance on the precedent set in Filip v. Block suggests that similar negligence claims may face challenges if they are not filed within the appropriate timeframe.
Going forward, this decision may affect how insurance agents communicate with clients about coverage details and the importance of ensuring that all requested vehicles or items are included in policies. It also serves as a reminder to clients to verify their coverage to avoid potential gaps that could lead to denied claims.
What's Next
While the Trainos have lost this appeal, it is unclear if they will seek further legal recourse or if there are related cases pending. The court's ruling is final unless appealed to a higher court, which the Trainos may consider given the implications of the decision.
Read Next
Indiana Court of Appeals rules on CorVel, Memorial Hospital case
Court affirms termination of father's parental rights in Indiana
Indiana Court affirms murder conviction of Charles Miles
Vermont court denies motion to amend wrongful death complaint
Vermont court dismisses eviction case against Catherine Morrill
Vermont court rules on timber harvest dispute case









