A U.S. District Court has denied a motion for default judgment against the Syrian Arab Republic in a case involving victims of a 2005 bombing in Jordan. The ruling affects plaintiffs Michael Anthony Butler and Randa Mahmoud Yaqoub, who sought damages for injuries sustained during the attack. The court's decision highlights the importance of presenting sufficient evidence to support claims under the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act (FSIA).
The case, Butler v. Syrian Arab Republic, was filed on November 19, 2026, under Civil Action No. 2024-3587. The plaintiffs, along with their family members, are seeking compensation for injuries they claim to have suffered in a suicide bombing that took place at the Grand Hyatt hotel in Amman, Jordan. This attack resulted in numerous fatalities and injuries, and the plaintiffs argue that Syria should be held liable for their suffering.
The dispute centers around whether the plaintiffs can establish their claims against Syria under the FSIA, which provides a framework for suing foreign nations in U.S. courts. The plaintiffs requested the court to take judicial notice of a previous ruling that found Syria responsible for the bombing in the related case of Thuneibat v. Syrian Arab Republic, decided in 2016. However, the court ruled that the plaintiffs did not provide adequate evidence to support their claims, leading to the denial of their motion.
In its ruling, the court stated, "Because Plaintiffs have not (yet) satisfied their evidentiary burden to secure the relief they seek, the Court DENIES WITHOUT PREJUDICE Plaintiffs’ motion." Magistrate Judge Matthew J. Sharbaugh emphasized that under the FSIA, a default judgment cannot be entered unless the claimant establishes their claim with satisfactory evidence. The court noted that while prior judicial findings may help link Syria to the attack, they do not suffice to prove the specific claims made by the plaintiffs.
The court explained that the plaintiffs failed to present evidence demonstrating that their injuries were caused by the bombing. Additionally, they did not provide proof that they met the statutory requirements necessary to pursue their claims under the FSIA. The court pointed out that the plaintiffs only referenced the previous case without offering any evidence specific to their own circumstances.
Judge Sharbaugh remarked, "Plaintiffs may file a renewed motion for default judgment supported by the proper evidentiary showing." He urged the plaintiffs to present sufficient evidence regarding both liability and damages in any future submissions. The court's decision underscores the necessity for plaintiffs to substantiate their claims with concrete evidence, rather than relying solely on prior rulings.
The impact of this ruling is significant for the plaintiffs and others in similar situations. It sets a precedent that emphasizes the importance of providing detailed evidence when seeking damages from foreign governments under the FSIA. The court's insistence on proper evidentiary support may affect how future cases are approached, particularly those involving claims of terrorism and foreign state liability.
Going forward, the plaintiffs have the opportunity to renew their motion for default judgment by January 22, 2027. They are encouraged to include comprehensive evidence that directly relates to their claims and injuries. The court's decision to deny the motion without prejudice allows the plaintiffs to correct their evidentiary shortcomings and strengthen their case.
Details were not available in the court filing regarding any potential appeals or related cases. However, the plaintiffs' ability to present a more robust case in their renewed motion will be crucial in determining the outcome of their claims against Syria.
Read Next
Court rules in favor of MedStar in negligence lawsuit
Court Denies Injunction in Student Loan Repayment Case
Court stays enforcement of ICSID award in Telefonica case
Hawaii Supreme Court denies petition for extraordinary writ
Court affirms dismissal of Marc Stephens' claims against CareOne
California Court rules against employer's arbitration clause










