A New York appellate court has upheld a decision denying accidental disability retirement benefits to a police detective who suffered a heart attack while performing his job duties. The ruling affects law enforcement professionals seeking similar benefits under the Retirement and Social Security Law. This case highlights the challenges faced by public employees when claiming benefits for injuries sustained during their work.
The case, titled Matter of Johnson v. DiNapoli, was decided on November 19, 2026, by the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York. The court's decision was based on the finding that the detective's heart attack did not qualify as an accident under the law. The ruling is significant as it sets a precedent for how similar cases may be evaluated in the future.
Background
William Johnson, the petitioner in this case, was a police detective assigned to the pistol permit unit. His duties included serving orders under the Secure Ammunition and Firearms Enforcement Act (SAFE Act), which requires individuals to surrender firearms under certain conditions. In this instance, Johnson and his partner were tasked with retrieving firearms from a subject who was reportedly hospitalized.
Upon arriving at the residence, Johnson and his partner were informed by the subject's mother that she had access to the firearms. She provided them with three handguns and an AK-15 assault rifle. The following day, Johnson experienced chest pains and was diagnosed with a heart attack. He subsequently applied for accidental disability retirement benefits, claiming that the heart attack was a direct result of the stress and anxiety he felt while handling the firearms.
The Ruling
The court ruled that Johnson's application for benefits was denied because his heart attack did not stem from an accident as defined by the Retirement and Social Security Law § 363. The court stated, "As the applicant, petitioner bore the burden of establishing that his disability arose from an accident within the meaning of the Retirement and Social Security Law, and respondent's determination in this regard will be upheld if supported by substantial evidence."
The court further clarified that an accident is defined as a "sudden, fortuitous mischance, unexpected, out of the ordinary, and injurious in impact." Johnson's heart attack, according to the court, resulted from the ordinary duties of his job, which included the inherent risk of encountering firearms. The ruling emphasized that injuries resulting from routine job duties do not qualify as accidental under the law.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for police officers and other public employees who seek accidental disability retirement benefits. The court's decision reinforces the idea that injuries arising from the normal course of employment, even if stressful, may not be considered accidents under the Retirement and Social Security Law. As a result, officers may face difficulties in proving that their injuries are eligible for benefits.
The court's ruling may also influence future cases involving similar claims. By establishing that the risk of encountering firearms was inherent in Johnson's job duties, the court has set a precedent that could affect how other claims are evaluated. Officers may need to demonstrate that their injuries resulted from unexpected events outside the scope of their regular duties to qualify for benefits.
What's Next
It is unclear if Johnson plans to appeal the court's decision. There are no related cases pending that could directly impact this ruling. However, the outcome of this case may encourage other officers to reevaluate their claims for accidental disability retirement benefits.
Read Next
Court modifies ruling on attorneys' fees in Galleria case
Court orders New York to disclose certain public records
Court upholds JPMorgan Chase's trust accounting in Rockefeller case
Hawaii Supreme Court denies petition for extraordinary writ
Court affirms dismissal of Marc Stephens' claims against CareOne
California Court rules against employer's arbitration clause










