The Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals has ruled that victims of the Hermit’s Peak and Calf Canyon wildfires cannot seek noneconomic damages from the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA). This decision affects numerous individuals who suffered losses due to the wildfires, which were ignited by controlled burns conducted by the U.S. Forest Service (USFS) in New Mexico.
The court's ruling on November 17, 2026, reverses a previous decision by a lower court that had allowed claims for noneconomic damages under the Hermit’s Peak/Calf Canyon Fire Assistance Act (the Act). The court found that the Act does not clearly waive the United States' sovereign immunity for such claims, which means FEMA is not liable for noneconomic damages like emotional distress or loss of enjoyment of life.
Background
The case, identified as Dolan v. Federal Emergency Management Agency, involves multiple plaintiffs, including Tobin Dolan and Lydia Dolan, who lost their homes and personal belongings in the fires. The wildfires began in April 2022 due to two controlled burns that got out of control. The Hermit’s Peak Fire was declared a major disaster, leading to the enactment of the Hermit’s Peak/Calf Canyon Fire Assistance Act in September 2022.
The Act was designed to provide compensation to those affected by the fires. However, it was limited to actual compensatory damages, and FEMA's interpretation of the Act excluded noneconomic damages. The plaintiffs challenged FEMA's regulations under the Administrative Procedures Act, arguing they should be able to recover for their noneconomic injuries.
The case reached the Tenth Circuit after a district court ruled in favor of the plaintiffs, stating that FEMA's interpretation was arbitrary and capricious. The district court ordered FEMA to consider claims for noneconomic damages. However, FEMA appealed the decision, arguing that the Act did not provide a clear waiver of sovereign immunity for such claims.
The Ruling
The Tenth Circuit, in its opinion, stated, "We do not find any such clear and unequivocal waiver" of the United States' sovereign immunity regarding noneconomic damages. The court emphasized that any waiver of sovereign immunity must be unambiguous and strictly construed in favor of the government.
The judges noted that while the Act allows for compensation for injuries caused by the fire, it does not explicitly include noneconomic damages. The court pointed out that Congress had structured the Act to provide a quick and limited compensation process, which would not be compatible with the complexity of calculating noneconomic damages.
The court concluded, "The Act, by using the phrase 'actual compensatory damages,' did not clearly and unequivocally waive sovereign immunity for claims seeking noneconomic damages." The ruling effectively limits the types of damages that victims can claim under the Act.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for victims of the Hermit’s Peak and Calf Canyon wildfires. It clarifies that while victims can seek compensation for economic losses, such as property damage, they cannot claim damages for emotional distress or other noneconomic injuries. This decision may discourage future claims against the government for similar disasters, as the limitations on recoverable damages could affect victims' willingness to pursue compensation.
The Tenth Circuit's decision also sets a precedent regarding the interpretation of federal statutes that involve waivers of sovereign immunity. It reinforces the principle that any waiver must be clearly stated in the law, which could impact future cases involving claims against the federal government.
What's Next
The plaintiffs may seek to appeal the Tenth Circuit's decision to the U.S. Supreme Court, but it remains unclear whether the Court will take up the case. Additionally, there may be related cases pending as other victims of the wildfires consider their options for compensation under the Act or through other legal channels.
Read Next
Tenth Circuit Rules on Public Employee Immunity Case
Court denies appeal from fraud convict seeking relief
Court affirms dismissal of Florez's Second Amendment claim
Vermont court denies motion to amend wrongful death complaint
Vermont court dismisses eviction case against Catherine Morrill
Vermont court rules on timber harvest dispute case









