A New York court has ruled in favor of tenants in a significant rent stabilization case involving a landlord's attempt to reclaim an apartment leased to a company. The Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York affirmed the lower court's decision, which denied the landlord's motion for summary judgment. This ruling affects the landlord, 38 East 64th Street, LLC, and its tenant, Nile, Inc., owned by E. Terese Carpenter, who has lived in the apartment for over 20 years.

The case, officially titled 38 E. 64th St., LLC v. Nile, Inc., was decided on November 19, 2026, under docket number Index No. 650912/24. The court's opinion highlights the complexities surrounding rent stabilization laws in New York City, particularly in cases where commercial leases are involved in residential units.

Background

The dispute began when 38 East 64th Street, LLC, the landlord, sought to recover possession of an apartment rented to Nile, Inc. The landlord claimed that the unit was being used improperly and sought to terminate the lease. Nile, Inc. is a company owned by E. Terese Carpenter, who has lived in the apartment since around 2006.

The landlord's argument centered around the assertion that the apartment was being used for commercial purposes, which would allow them to terminate the lease under the terms of the agreement. However, the case became complicated due to the apartment's history and its classification under rent stabilization laws. The landlord's claim was based on the belief that the lease was exclusive for business use, despite the building's certificate of occupancy permitting only residential use.

The case reached the Appellate Division after the Supreme Court in New York County denied the landlord's motion for summary judgment on May 19, 2025. The landlord sought to dismiss the defendants' counterclaims and affirmative defenses but was unsuccessful, leading to the appeal.

The Ruling

The Appellate Division ruled unanimously to affirm the lower court's decision. The judges noted that the Supreme Court correctly denied the landlord's motion for summary judgment. The court stated, "Under the circumstances presented, Supreme Court correctly denied plaintiff's motion." This ruling indicates that there were unresolved factual questions regarding the use of the apartment.

The court emphasized that if there is a question of fact about whether the premises are being used for mixed residential and commercial use, it must be resolved by a factfinder. The judges pointed out that the defendants had submitted sufficient evidence to raise questions about whether the unit was used for residential purposes with the landlord's knowledge and consent, which could invoke rent stabilization regulations.

Furthermore, the court highlighted that the landlord did not dispute the defendants' claims that they were required to enter into a commercial lease for an apartment that was previously subject to rent stabilization laws. The judges also noted that Carpenter had lived in the apartment for over 20 years, which further complicated the landlord's position.

Impact

This ruling has significant implications for both the landlord and tenants in New York City. It reinforces the protections afforded to tenants under rent stabilization laws, particularly in cases where landlords attempt to convert residential leases to commercial ones. The court's decision may deter landlords from pursuing similar actions in the future, knowing that tenants can challenge the legitimacy of such leases.

Additionally, the ruling sets a precedent regarding the interpretation of mixed-use properties and the responsibilities of landlords in complying with rent stabilization regulations. It highlights the importance of adhering to the terms of occupancy certificates and the potential legal consequences of failing to do so.

What's Next

Details were not available in the court filing regarding whether the landlord plans to appeal this decision. However, the case's outcome may influence other pending cases involving rent stabilization and commercial leases in New York City.