The U.S. Court of Federal Claims ruled against the Creekside Park Owners’ Association and other landowners in a case involving the conversion of a former railway line into a public trail. The court found that the landowners did not have a compensable property interest in the land beneath the rail line, affecting 19 individual claims. This decision is significant for property owners involved in similar rails-to-trails disputes across the nation.
The case, Creekside Park Owners’ Association v. United States (Docket No. 23-772), centers on a 2.58-mile segment of the Seattle and West Coast Railway in Woodinville, Washington. The landowners argued that the federal government’s conversion of the railway to a public trail constituted a taking of their reversionary interest in the land. The court's ruling clarifies the legal standards surrounding property rights in rails-to-trails cases.
Background
The plaintiffs in this case are 19 landowners who own property adjacent to the former railway line. They claim that the railway only acquired an easement over their land, meaning they retain ownership of the land beneath the railway up to its centerline. The plaintiffs based their claims on historical deeds and condemnations dating back to the late 1800s, which they argued granted only easement rights to the railway.
The dispute arose after the railway's successor, GNP RLY, Inc., filed a notice of exemption to convert the railway line into a public trail. The Surface Transportation Board approved this conversion, prompting the landowners to file their complaint, asserting their ownership rights. The plaintiffs sought partial summary judgment, arguing that the government had taken their property without compensation.
The Ruling
Judge Kathryn C. Davis of the U.S. Court of Federal Claims issued the ruling on November 16, 2026. The court denied the plaintiffs' motion for partial summary judgment and granted the government's cross-motion for summary judgment. The court concluded that the plaintiffs failed to demonstrate ownership of the land underlying the right of way.
The court stated, "no genuine issues of material fact remain for trial and that Plaintiffs fail to demonstrate ownership of the land underlying the right of way."
The court found that the historical deeds granted the railway fee simple title to the land, rather than merely an easement. The judge emphasized that the language of the deeds did not limit the railway's rights to railroad use only, which is a critical factor in determining property ownership in such cases. The court's decision reinforces the principle that property rights can be complex, especially in cases involving historical land use.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for landowners involved in rails-to-trails cases, as it clarifies the legal interpretation of property rights associated with former railway lines. The court's decision could discourage similar claims by other landowners who believe they have retained ownership of land beneath converted railway lines.
The ruling could also influence future cases regarding the conversion of rail lines to trails, as it sets a precedent for how courts may interpret historical deeds and property rights. It highlights the importance of the specific language used in property conveyances and the need for landowners to thoroughly understand their rights when dealing with government actions.
What's Next
The plaintiffs may seek to appeal the decision, although details on any potential appeal were not available in the court filing. There are no related cases pending that were mentioned in the opinion.
Read Next
Court allows Alamo City Engineering to amend contract claim
Court dismisses vaccine injury claim for insufficient proof
Court Denies Vaccine Injury Claim of Stacy Wyble
Illinois court reverses dismissal of postconviction petition
Court Denies Pseudonym for Plaintiff in Doe v. Trump Case
California Court rules on drug testing in juvenile case










