A New York appellate court has ruled in a family farm dispute that affects ownership rights and property access. The court upheld a decision denying a request for an easement by necessity on the Chapel Farm property. This ruling impacts the Starowitz family, who have been involved in a legal battle over their jointly owned farm.
The case, Starowitz v. Star Growers Farm, LLC, was decided on November 20, 2026, by the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York. The court's decision is significant as it clarifies the requirements for establishing an easement by necessity, which is crucial for property owners seeking access to their land.
Background
The parties involved in this case are Leo D. Starowitz, Jr., the plaintiff, and his brothers Andrew M. Starowitz, Frank L. Starowitz, and John F. Starowitz, who are the defendants. Together, they own and operate Star Growers Farm, which is structured as multiple limited liability companies and corporations. Each brother holds a one-quarter interest in these entities.
The dispute arose after disagreements among the brothers regarding the operation of the farm. In response to these conflicts, Leo D. Starowitz initiated legal action seeking the judicial dissolution of the farm's entities. The case reached the appellate court after the Supreme Court of Genesee County issued an order in May 2025 that denied the defendants' request for an easement and awarded a vehicle to the plaintiff.
The Ruling
The appellate court ruled unanimously to affirm the lower court's decision. The court found that the defendants failed to meet the burden of proof required to establish an easement by necessity. According to the ruling, "the necessity must exist in fact and not as a mere convenience" and must be indispensable for the reasonable use of the adjacent property.
The court noted that the defendants did not provide clear and convincing evidence that the easement they sought was absolutely necessary. Instead, they only demonstrated that their need to use the proposed easement through the plaintiff's land was "nothing more than a mere convenience." The court emphasized that the defendants had access to their non-tillable land from a public road, which undermined their claim for an easement.
Additionally, the court addressed the award of a 1988 Chevrolet Suburban to the plaintiff. The ruling stated that the settlement agreement allowed for the transfer of various vehicles, and the court had the discretion to determine which vehicles were included in that agreement. The court concluded that the 1988 Chevrolet Suburban was among the vehicles to which the plaintiff was entitled.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for property rights and easement laws in New York. It clarifies that property owners must demonstrate a genuine necessity for an easement, rather than simply showing that it would be more convenient. This decision could influence future cases involving easement disputes, particularly in family-owned businesses where ownership and access rights are contested.
The ruling also highlights the importance of clear agreements during settlements. The court's interpretation of the settlement agreement regarding the vehicle transfer illustrates how courts can exercise discretion in determining the terms of agreements made by parties in disputes.
What's Next
Details were not available in the court filing regarding any potential for an appeal. It remains to be seen if the defendants will seek further legal recourse in this matter or if any related cases are pending.
Read Next
Court rules in favor of worker injured in ladder fall case
Court to Hear Case on Abandoned Mobile Home in Rockland County
New York Court rules on podiatric malpractice case
Nevada court affirms ruling against vexatious litigant Van Damme
Nevada court overturns contempt ruling in custody dispute
Nevada Court Denies Hollman, Inc.'s Petition for Writ










